"What Happens at Nightfall," Lauren Willig
Lauren is a friend and writing partner of my daughter-in-law, the author Beatriz Williams. Both have attended Drones Club (fans of P.G. Wodehouse) dinners in New York, which is where I met her.
Sydney M. Williams
Burrowing into Books
What Happens at Nightfall, Lauren Willig
November 19, 2026
“It was like a funhouse, the twisting roads, the greenery that deadened
sound, the glimpses of things half seen, teasing the corners of her eyes.”
On Green-Wood Cemetery
What Happens at Nightfall, 2026
Lauren Willig (1977 - )
This is a story that blends spooks, history and romance with humor.
Lauren Willig has many attributes, including degrees from Yale and Harvard and inclusion on the New York Times Best-Seller list. But what I like best about her is that she is sound on P.G. Wodehouse. While this novel of hers is about demons and mostly set in Green-Wood Cemetery in Brooklyn, Wodehouse stories are light, whimsical, set in Edwardian England, involving kind, mentally-deficient young men, along with efficient, intellectually-superior, young women. However, Wodehouse did not totally shy from spiritualism. In the short story “Honeysuckle Cottage” he wrote: “...there’s a malignant spell over the place, a sort of miasma of sentimentalism.” And, like Wodehouse, Ms. Willig had fun with her novel.
With her knowledge of history, interest in classicism, fascination with the occult, fondness for romance, delight in humor and familiarity with Green-Wood Cemetery, Ms. Willig has written a page-turner. She tells us that her knowledge of the cemetery is recent, but it is obviously thorough – ...its “twisting pathways here are a lot like life.” The cemetery contains 570,000 “Permanent New Yorkers,” on 478 acres. With more than 7000 trees, it is an official, accredited, Level III Arboretum.
Like all good stories, What Happens at Nightfall must be read to be appreciated, and this essayist does not want to spoil it for the reader. The heroine is 38-year-old Jess (Jacinta Waters). The book opens on a tour of Green-Wood, to which Jess has been invited by her friend Kimmy (Kameka Olsen). During the tour Jess becomes separated from the group and stumbles upon Ben, the eleven-year-old son of Adam Chervinsky. (Adam is a 40-something widower and the cemetery’s arborist.)
The tour’s guide is a somewhat imperious history PhD candidate, Ingrid Morteson. Conveniently for the story, she was at Yale with Adam and Kate, Adam’s deceased wife. The other main character is Melinda, Adam’s fifteen-year-old daughter. Kate was tragically killed while jogging four years ago, before this story opens; but her family’s name, Vanderwilt, lives on (If that is a proper phrase when writing of the dead?). Much of the action takes place in Green-Wood’s Vanderwilt Mausoleum.
Without going into detail, the story is the battle between Belfagor, a demon who sows disputes among people, leading his victims to lives of evil; on the other side are Jess, Kimmy, Ingrid Adam and Adam’s children. Combining historical fact with a vivid imagination, she leaves the reader startled and laughing, all the while rooting for Jess, Adam and his children.
Nightfall is an annual, late October-evening, event at Green-Wood. I never attended, but I enjoyed Lauren’s book and am sure Wodehouse would have as well.
Labels: Lauren Willig, P.G. Wodehouse


