Thursday, July 19, 2018

"The Liberal Order Has Become Illiberal"

Sydney M. Williams

Thought of the Day 
“The Liberal Order Has Become Illiberal”
July 19, 2018

“We must especially beware of that small group of selfish men who would
 clip the wings of the American eagle in order to feather their own nests.”
                                                                                                President Franklin Roosevelt
                                                                                                State of the Union, January 1941

The so-called “liberal world order” arrived in the aftermath of World War II –an epic war between forces of good and evil. Millions had experienced the horrors of a hot war. In victory, the Allies wanted to ensure that such wanton killing would never happen again. It was a time when moral absolutes reigned. Tolkien’s “Lord of the Rings” and C.S. Lewis’ “Chronicles of Narnia” were written just before and just after the War. Both fantasy parables were based on the Biblical notion of good triumphing over evil.

In the wake of World War II, democratic nations agreed to create an international system – a liberal order – rooted in democracy, the rule of law and mutual respect for each country’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. It would be inspired by the U.S., but not submissive to her. Global organizations like the UN, NATO, WTO, World Bank and IMF were created to provide a forum for parties to meet, transact and discuss. But it was fear of mutually assured destruction – the threat of nuclear weapons and the power of a strong military – that kept major powers at bay during the first four and a half decades after the War. 

In the aftermath of the War, the United States was the only nation in a position to help revive its Allies…and its former enemies, and it did so. The U.S. had emerged from the War largely unscathed. Between the years 1940 and 1945, its economy expanded 75%, while those of other major combatants shrunk. The Marshall Plan, the Truman Doctrine and the deployment of U.S. troops provided economic assistance and acted as a buffer against the nascent spread of Communism.

The world evolved after 1945. While liberal capitalism helped drive economic growth and prosperity in the West, the East remained imprisoned, yoked to dictatorships and subject to the economic deprivation of Communism. The Cold War was eventually won by the forces of freedom, capitalism and democracy against confinement, poverty and authoritarianism. With the collapse of the Soviet Union, the United States became the world’s sole hegemonic power. In 1990 President George H. W. Bush addressed the United Nations: “Out of these troubled times, our objective – a new world order – can emerge. Today, that new world is struggling to be born, a world quite different from the one we have known.” Unfortunately, the collapse of Communism created a vacuum of leadership in the West. The Cold War had been won, but what to do with the spoils? Reagan and Thatcher, the giants who had slain the Soviet dragon, were gone.

Over the past several decades, as politics in Europe moved inexorably to the left, American capitalism became questioned. The credit collapse of 2008 added fuel to those flames of concern, in part because most analyses ignored the consequential role played by government leading to that crisis. In the eyes of Europeans, the U.S. was no longer the savior it had been in 1945. In fact, it became begrudged. Simultaneously, to middle Americans, Europeans appeared condescending, arrogant, hypocritical, ethereal and weak. They were seen as Elois to the Morlocks who had liberated them. Americans came to resent the costs of defending a people who seemed unappreciative, self-centered, dependent on state-funded amenities and accepting as their due security provided by Americans. 

Over seventy years things change, and change happened in the West. Nationalism, which had been blamed for the rise of Nazism in Germany and fascism in Japan, became a component of liberalism during the Cold War, as the West urged nationalists to help defeat Communism. Keep in mind as well, Brits, French, Belgians, Scandinavians, Chinese and others had taken pride in their nations’ defeat of Hitler and Hirohito. Today, European elites condemn what they see as a rebirth of nationalism in Eastern and Central Europe, especially when progressive policies are challenged. Ivan Krastev, Chairman for Liberal Studies in Sofia, put it this way in a recent article for The Guardian: “Postwar German democracy was built on the assumption that nationalism leads ineluctably to Nazism…But, unlike German nationalists in 1945, central European nationalists in 1989 felt they’d come out the winners…” 

Sovereign rights and laws, once the domain of independent states, were relegated to bureaucrats in Brussels. Deprivation led to excess. Rising costs associated with ever-higher welfare payments, deteriorating demographics, increasing debt and dependence on an omnipotent rich uncle across the sea. In this fiscal morass, a debt-laden future was seen as acceptable to ensure a comfortable present.

Aggravating the situation, unfettered immigration policies put strains on cultures and economies. A rise in Islamic terrorism, emanating from the Middle East and Africa, and a return of socialist authoritarianism in Central America created floods of refugees – some in need, but among them many who look for “freebies” and a few were intent on harming their host country. Immigration, the engine of growth and diversity, became a fulcrum for division. From globalism emerged multiculturalism and then a concomitant dispersal of moral clarity. The lines between good and evil became blurred, washed away by a desire for inclusion. Under the guise of political correctness, the West adopted a theocracy of relativism. When asked whether the population of Muslims in Europe was a “very or somewhat” serious threat, more than 60% of respondents in Belgium, France, Germany, Netherlands and England said yes. Yet, open borders are favored by many Western leaders in Europe and in the U.S. As Mark Steyn recently wrote, when the concerns of the majority are “regarded as unmentionable by mainstream parties, you have a crisis of democracy.”

For Americans, what is happening is consequential. A recent “Quality of Life” ranking by US News placed the United States 17thin the world, behind most of those helped. Social welfare states have been abetted and protected by the United States. Assumptions and expectations are that the status quo ante would continue, notwithstanding the human cost to administrative-led welfare states. In a recent op-ed in The Wall Street Journal, Erica Komisar, psychoanalyst and author of “Being There: Why Prioritizing Motherhood in the First Three Years Matters,” wrote about Sweden, which has the highest personal income tax in the world: “While Sweden has worked hard to eliminate material poverty, it is creating a society whose children are suffering from emotional poverty.” A warning more than a quarter of a century ago by then Director of the UN World Health Organization Brock Chisholm portends ominously: “To achieve world government, it is necessary to remove from the minds of men their individualism, loyalty to family, traditions, national patriotism and religious dogmas.” His words are reminiscent of George Orwell’s 1984.

As much as some Euro-centrics would like Europe to become politically, as well as economically, united, they should keep in mind that Empires have been tried in Europe and all ultimately failed. Think of the Holy Roman Empire, the epic battles between France and England during the Hundred Years War, Philip the II of Spain, the Austrian-Hungarian Empire, Napoleon and Nazi Germany. When the United States was formed, the history of individual colonies stretched back less than 200 years. The principal language was English, and a large percentage of the population came from the British Isles. Even so, the forming of the Union was not easy, and a Civil War had to be fought eighty years later to solidify the Republic that had been created in 1787. History, culture, religion, customs and language separate nations. Democracy, free trade and trade associations, forums to meet, student exchanges and the like are measures that help maintain friendships, alliances and peace, without forming an imperfect union.

If the EU were truly liberal, it would allow the UK to withdraw and then work out the mutually best trade, defense, cultural and immigration policies and practices. It would ask why and for what reason did Britain choose to withdraw? It would want to know, what is it that can be done better? It would make it easier for the aspirant to succeed by lessening regulations and reducing taxes. It would agree to eliminate all tariffs. It would become self-reliant in terms of defense, and it would face the harsh reality of domestic, social welfare policies that burden future generations, and which fail to account for changes in demographics.

At bottom, it is the cavalier attitude toward defense that is most troubling. In the years since the collapse of the Soviet Union, defense spending in the U.S. declined from 6.8% of GDP, during the height of the arms buildup in the 1980s, to 3.5% last year. Even so, as a percent of GDP, the United States still spends almost twice as much on defense as do France, Germany, the UK, Japan, Australia, Canada and Austria. Given the world we live in, amidst the threats that abound, we cannot afford to let defense spending slip further. Mr. Trump is not denying the relevance of NATO. He is asking, in his blunt and undiplomatic way, that beneficiaries re-think their obligations to help pay the price. He wants people to acknowledge the presence of good and evil, to stand up for the former and against the latter. As well, he wants trade with no tariffs. The current system has disadvantaged the United States, with deficits being garnered by the U.S. and surpluses gathered by those like Germany. The result, its trade deficit has ballooned, along with federal deficits and debt. In 1990, after a spurt in defense spending that brought down the Soviet Union, national debt was about 65% of GDP. Last year, it was 105%. The United States’ role as a rich uncle available for handouts is coming, by necessity, to an end. Nephews and nieces have done well and are now being asked to bear more of the burden, even if it means reducing the beloved welfare state.

The stories of Tolkien and C.S. Lewis remain relevant. Evil persists, in the guise of Islamic terrorists and in the re-birth of a territorial-aggressive Russia, and a China intent on dominating Asian seas and trading routes to Africa and the Middle East. Iran is on a glide toward nuclear weapons. Syria’s Assad remains in power. Kim Jong-un clings to his nuclear weapons. But, I believe we must also watch warily the growth of the Administrative State – executive and administrative orders, without legislative support, and non-elected district judges who issue nationwide injunctions. The risk to liberty too often emanates from inside. A Freedom House report last January noted that seventy-one countries suffered net declines in political rights and civil liberties, while thirty-five countries experienced gains: “Democracy faced its most serious crisis in decades in 2017.”

It is democracy and republicanism that is wanted – the voices of the people and their elected representatives, not sanctuary cities, political correctness, “hash-tags,” “diversity,” “victimization” or edicts from Washington, London, Paris, Berlin or Brussels that is critical to liberalism. Tolerance, respect, universal values, fairness, equality of opportunity and obeisance to laws and cultural norms are necessary guidelines for a civilized, liberal society.  

In the rubric at the start of this essay, Roosevelt was speaking of dictators in Europe and Japan, but his warning, in both a domestic and global sense, has relevance today.







Labels: , , , , , ,

Monday, February 12, 2018

"The Memo"

Sydney M. Williams

Thought of the Day
“The Memo”
February 12, 2018

“Giving money and power to government
is like giving whiskey and car keys to teen-age boys.”
                                                                                                P.J. O’Rourke (1947-)
                                                                                                Parliament of Whores, 1991

Democracy is fragile. It must be handled with care. Sunlight is a disinfectant, but too much can be incendiary. Conformity in behavior is critical to civility, but conformity in ideas leads to ignorance. Government is the glue that binds a people into a nation, but when the rule of law is breached by government, tyranny supplants democracy.

The release of “the memo” did not prove or disprove any collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia. It did not commend or condemn Christopher Steele, Fusion GPS, or the dossier. It should not affect the Mueller investigation. It was not incendiary in the way Democrats forecast. But it was revealing in that it showed how usurpation of power can destroy trust in government and damage the fairness and equality necessary to a democratic society. The memo showed that agencies of the federal government (the DOJ and the FBI), in misleading the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISC), conspired with one political party and candidate (Democrats and Hillary Clinton) to the detriment of another (Republicans and Donald Trump). Whether it was an act of omission or commission is less important than the fact that the FBI and DOJ were not honest in making their case before the FISC, regarding the request to wiretap Carter Page. An editorial in the Wall Street Journal put it well: “We recognize the need for the FBI to sometimes spy on Americans to keep the country safe, but this is a power that should never be abused.” The people who work for the DOJ and the FBI work for the American people, not a specific candidate or political party.

We all have opinions, government employees included. But the latter must not let opinions influence their work. From the start, I have never believed that the Machiavellian Vladimir Putin preferred Donald Trump to Hillary Clinton. I found (and find) the proposition ludicrous. Mr. Trump was an unknown. He was (and is) volatile and unpredictable. Mrs. Clinton was disliked by Mr. Putin, but she was a known known, as Donald Rumsfeld might have put it. Mr. Putin had dealt with her as a Secretary of State and had known her as a U.S. Senator and as the wife of a U.S. President. He had had dealings with the Clinton Foundation. He knew how to handle her, whereas Mr. Trump was a wild card. We have all read Peter Strzok’s (former lead FBI investigator into possible collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia) e-mail of September 2016 to his paramour Lisa Page, an FBI lawyer, about the alleged collusion: “My gut sense and concern is there’s no big there there.” If collusion existed, I believe it was between the Obama Administration/Clinton campaign and the DOJ/FBI, not the Trump campaign and Russia.

Politics is a blood sport. Democrats and the Clinton campaign wanted knowledge of any possible Russian connections Donald Trump might have had, thus the hiring of Christopher Steele. To obfuscate payments for the report they were seeking, they had their Washington law firm, Perkins Coie, pay for the research. Perkins Coie then hired Fusion GPS, a Washington-based commercial research and strategic intelligence firm. In turn, they hired Christopher Steele, a former British agent, sometime FBI informant and known Trump hater, to prepare the dossier, which he did – a 35-page document later described by FBI Director James Comey as “salacious and unverified.” Mr. Steele was allegedly paid $160,000 by the DNC and Clinton campaign. And the FBI paid to obtain the dossier. Despite Mr. Comey’s characterization of the report, he, along with Deputy FBI Director Andrew McCabe, signed three FISA warrant requests to surveil Mr. Page, using the Steele dossier as an essential basis for the request. They did so without disclosing the connection of Mr. Steele to the DNC and Mrs. Clinton. As well, the FISA request cited a news story that had appeared in Yahoo News, but they failed to mention that the article was largely based on an interview with the discredited Mr. Steele, who had also leaked elements of the dossier to media organizations, in violation of FBI orders. The request did not mention that the DOJ official who met with Steele, Bruce Ohr, had a wife who was employed by Fusion GPS and who had worked on the dossier.

Before being released, Democrats claimed “the memo” would damage national security, which it did not. A rebuttal of non-politicized facts should be released, a move supported by Republicans, as should the transcripts to the FISA Court, as well as the name of the judge who authorized the wiretap. Normally such information would be kept private, but these are not normal times. Democracies demand a disinterested press and government employees who are above politics – men and women who accept the will of the people, not those who undermine the democratic process and who try to derail a duly nominated candidate.

The incident of the memo is a reminder of the fragility of democracy. It has become common among the Left to claim Trump as a wannabe dictator. While I believe we must always be vigilant and skeptical, that is not, in my opinion, the risk we face. Of far greater concern is the gradual assumption of power by an administrative state via an unaccountable bureaucracy dependent on big government. It is the growth of regulations that inhibit liberties that should concern us. It is the university that denies conservative viewpoints that should have us worried. It is a media that has foregone any semblance of fairness and disinterested reporting that should cause us disquiet. It is an FBI and Department of Justice that do the bidding of one political party to the detriment of another that threatens liberty. The actions exposed in “the memo” are reminiscent of a time when J. Edgar Hoover’s FBI abused the constitutional rights of those who challenged his authority. Considering risk to democracy in this way, the Obama Administration, with its expansion of agencies such as the EPA, HHS, CFPB and the FCC – not to mention Lois Lerner and the IRS – was far more dangerous to liberty than Mr. Trump.

Authoritarians do emerge. And they can come from segments of the population that have been ignored by elites, like religious, straight, working-class, white males – deplorables, as Hillary Clinton described them – who had been belittled and dismissed by Democrats focused on identity politics. But to succeed, an authoritarian requires an accommodative press and the acceptance by cultural institutions. When presidents have seized special powers, as did Lincoln, Wilson and FDR, it was during a time of war. Franklin Roosevelt came closest to assuming extraordinary powers, when he attempted to expand the Supreme Court, interned Japanese-Americans and ran successfully for president four times. He had the media on his side, but he was stymied by Congress in the first instance. The internment camps ended before the War concluded, in December 1944, and the ratification of the 22nd Amendment in 1951 prohibited any future President from serving more than two terms. Lyndon Johnson’s “Great Society” expanded the reach of government, as did Mr. Obama’s focus on “not letting a crisis go to waste.” Nevertheless, it is Mr. Trump who is slammed as a Fascist by the far left, the media, on college campuses and among pseudo intellectuals on cable TV and in Hollywood. What the memo exposed should concern all thinking Americans.


In 1972, five men working on behalf of the Nixon re-election campaign burglarized the Democratic National Committee offices in the Watergate office complex. That was a crime. The scandal was worsened when an attempt by the Administration to enlist the CIA and the FBI to squash the investigation failed, and President Nixon was forced – rightfully – to resign. In the current situation, the Obama Administration successfully enlisted the DOJ and the FBI in a failed attempt to thwart the election of Donald Trump in 2016. In the first instance, democracy won; in the second, it lost – at least so far, as the only head that seems at risk is that of the victim, Mr. Trump.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Monday, December 18, 2017

"RAT - Resist Anything Trump"

Sydney M. Williams

Thought of the Day
“RAT – Resist Anything Trump”
December 18, 2017

“You see, the point is that the strongest man in the world is he who stands alone.”
                                                                                                            Henrik Ibsen

Resistance is ancient. A few brave men and women have always stood against tyranny. The movie “Spartacus” depicted a slave rebellion in ancient Rome. The Protestant Reformation was resistance against Catholicism. Henry David Thoreau gave us civil disobedience. We associate resistance with the French and Polish undergrounds during the Second World War. More recently, George Lucas used resistance as the center of his epic film “Star Wars.” Leia Organa founds a small military force, “The Resistance,” to combat the First Order, which had risen from the ashes of the Galactic Empire.

Resistance is a call for freedom and a means to defend liberty. It was resistance against King John that established the Magna Carta in 1215, which limited the powers of the king. American patriots resisted the imposition of taxes, by tossing tea into Boston harbor in 1773. Woodrow Wilson noted that “the history of liberty is the history of resistance.”

But today’s resistance against Donald Trump has none of that legitimacy or idealism. It’s driven by hatred. It grew out of last year’s election, when Mr. Trump, anti-establishment and an outsider to Washington’s Beltway politics, was elected President. It claims spontaneity, but is led by a group called Indivisible (www.indivisible.org), and comprised of organizations like Black Lives Matter, Women’s March Global and the Center for Community Change. It has been funded by Democracy Alliance, which has steered more than $600 million toward selected liberal groups since its inception in 2005, and by MoveOn.org, the PAC set up by billionaire George Soros. It is supported by those in the media who decry Mr. Trump’s “toxic and menacing presidency,” as L.A. Kaufman, in The Guardian, put it. The “resistance” has the endorsement of Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton. Organizing for Action, the PAC set up by Mr. Obama in 2008, has been relaunched with its purpose to derail Mr. Trump’s Presidency. Ms. Clinton incorporated Organizing for Action, a PAC to help fund resistance groups, transferring $800,000 from her campaign funds.

Most disconcerting, “resistance” is embedded in federal bureaucracies, like the IRS, the State Department and the Department of Justice. It descends from resistance to conservatives – recall the stone-walling of Lois Lerner at the IRS in 2015? Today, the State Department is boycotting the President’s Jerusalem policy, as can be seen with 15-year-old American, Menachem Zivotofsky who was born in Jerusalem and is trying to get his passport to say he was born in Israel. We saw it in James Comey’s testimony, and in the anti-Trump e-mails between Peter Strzok and his paramour, Lisa Page. It was seen in Sally Yates, a holdover from the Obama Administration, refusing to enforce a legal order on immigration, and in the refusal of Leandra English to hand over control of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau after the President had appointed Mick Mulvaney to be interim head. It can be seen in the Senate’s “slow-walking” of hundreds of administrative appointments, and in the endless investigations into alleged Russian-Trump collusion.

The “resistance” has been abetted by a press more interested in advocacy than news. In his recent history, The Second World Wars, Victor Davis Hanson writes about one of Mussolini’s characteristics: “…appreciating the power of propaganda, especially ideological driven journalism.” The “resistance” has the same skill; they are fortunate in an accommodating media. The repeated use of fake stories – even those later retracted – serves their purpose. As Lee Smith of the Weekly Standard and Hudson Institute recently wrote: “When you repeatedly publish ‘news’ that isn’t true, you’re no longer in the news business.”

Granted, Mr. Trump makes an easy target. With his dyed hair, Tweets, solecisms, vulgarisms, complex financial history and three wives, he is a caricature of a modern-day Mr. Potter, as portrayed by Lionel Barrymore in “It’s a Wonderful Life.” In looks and behavior, he is the antithesis of the bureaucrat who, mired in establishment muck, speaks impeccably. Lacking suavity, Mr. Trump treats people the same, regardless of race, sex, age or religion. He doesn’t differentiate, as his recent Tweet to Senator Gillibrand (D-NY) showed. (He used the same words “will do anything” about Mitt Romney.) He does not subscribe to identity politics. He does not compartmentalize voters. He is a threat to a progressive culture that has dominated Washington for the last eighty years.

Mr. Trump’s character prevents me from being a whole-hearted endorser of the man. However, I agree with most of his policies, especially those that relate to the economy, taxes, regulation and his handling of Islamic extremists. Mr. Trump is that rare individual who says what he means and means what he says. Diplomacy and the English language are not his strong suits. I admire him for calling out the sanctimony and hypocrisy that have become the norm in Washington. We see the latter in the pomposity and duplicity of Nancy Pelosi and Chuck Schumer, who, with each Presidential Tweet, dash toward cameras and microphones, to condemn him with feigned astonishment and undisguised scorn.

What has happened in the past twelve months is unprecedented in American politics, with the exception of the Civil War. Political parties have disagreed, but none since John Breckinridge in 1861 have tried to destroy a Presidency so blatantly. Smooth transitions in democracies are integral. John Adams and Thomas Jefferson were political enemies, but when Jefferson won the election of 1800, Adams did not try to sabotage Jefferson’s administration. Lyndon Johnson and Hubert Humphrey did not try to invalidate Richard Nixon, and Gerald Ford gave way graciously to Jimmy Carter. Carter, while disappointed with his loss in 1980, did not impair Ronald Reagan. George H.W. Bush did not undercut Bill Clinton. The Clintons may have trashed the White House, but they didn’t interfere with President Bush. And George Bush did not criticize Barack Obama. A Presidential transition is the point when democracies are most at risk. In the past, outgoing Party’s stood by and let the new take over – not enthusiastically, but not as resistors.

Think about it: After leaving office, Jimmy Carter built houses with Habitat for Humanity; Ronald Reagan disappeared into the mists of Alzheimer’s; George H.W. Bush enjoyed his large family; Bill Clinton went to New York and made a couple of hundred million dollars; George W. Bush went to Texas and painted portraits of veterans of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars. Barack Obama, however, is staying in Washington to set up a PAC to help discredit his successor.

Democracies are fragile, so vigilance is wanted. They are susceptible to the whims of powerful, but evil, seductive and persuasive men and women – autocrats who can come from either the right or the left. In my opinion, the risks are greater from the left, as those manning the ramparts – the Fourth Estate – have eyes right, watching for Fascists and nationalists. They ignore the slow-growth, but insidious, left-leaning administrative state, which is quietly gathering strength and size. The federal government employs two million people – overseen by 535 elected representatives. The bureaucrats who day-to-day manage those employees are, for the most part, progressives who, because of where and how they live, are largely immune from the effects of their policies – programs said to be beneficent, but designed to give them more power.

Keep in mind, it is mice that do not stir, when “the stockings [are] hung by the chimney with care.” As for RATs, they’re still scurrying around, and will be on Christmas Eve. Nonetheless, enjoy the Holidays!



Labels: , , , ,