Friday, June 9, 2023

"Hope"

 It is fitting that an essay on ‘hope’ should be sent during the week we remember the 79th anniversary of the Normandy invasion, for it was hope for its success that filled the hearts of the millions of those who for most of a decade had lived under the boot of Nazism.

 

Sydney M. Williams

www.swtotd.blogspot.com

 

Thought of the Day

“Hope”

June 9, 2023

 

“Optimism is the faith that leads to achievement.

Nothing can be done without hope and confidence.”

                                                                                                                                Helen Keller (1880-1968)

                                                                                                                                Optimism, 1903

 

Hope is a verb and a noun. It reflects one’s optimism and posits one’s positive, achievable goals. It should not be confused with Walter Mitty-like grandiose dreams. It speaks of the possible. Hope has been around as long as humans. Speaking to the Corinthians five decades after the death of Jesus, Paul spoke of the need for faith, hope, and charity. Helen Keller, blind and deaf since age two, wrote the words quoted in the rubric above while a student at Radcliffe. Two months before his death, Martin Luther King, Jr. spoke in Washington, D.C.: “We must accept finite disappointment, but never lose infinite hope.” 

 

Politically, hope has been absent in the U.S. for almost a generation. From the end of World War II until the assassination of President Kennedy, America was filled with promise. We faced challenges. Bomb shelters were built for fear of nuclear annihilation, and the 1957 Soviet launch of Sputnik lent concern that the Soviets were leading in the space race. But our nation’s response was positive, and we felt safe. On May 25, 1961, in a speech before a joint session of Congress, President Kennedy promised to put a man on the moon before the end of the decade – a goal the nation achieved when Neil Armstrong stepped onto the moon’s surface on July 20, 1969. Sadly, Kennedy did not live to see this, but the U.S., during those years, had a can-do spirit, driven by admiration for Country, self-confidence, and hope.

 

In the second half of the 1960s, with Vietnam, student riots, and a drug-infested and sexually voyeuristic Woodstock, hope dissipated.  Malaise set in during the 1970s, as the country experienced Watergate and the first ever resignation of a President, the ignoble evacuation of Saigon, an oil shock, inflation, prolonged recession, and a stock market that treaded water over ten years. The confidence we felt in those post-War years was gone. But by summer’s end 1982 a feeling of relief spread across the land, and the stock market began to rise. The dragon of inflation had been slain by Fed Chairman Paul Volcker, at the cost of a short but steep recession. Ronald Reagan, a gifted speaker filled with optimism and confident in America’s future, had been elected President in 1980. His “morning in America” persisted into the 1990s, only to be impaled by a tech bubble and the attack on September 11, when Islamic extremists flew four airliners into the World Trade Center, the Pentagon, and a field in Shanksville, Pennsylvania, killing almost 3000 civilians.  

 

In the ensuing twenty-two years, with credit and bank crises, spiraling debt, inflation, and political division, we have never regained that sense of confidence and hope. Many thought the election of Barack Obama signaled such a return. But unfortunately, he chose to deepen racial divide. Today the nation is filled with anger, despair, and a sense of helplessness. Even Moms for liberty is seen as a hate group. We are divided by race, gender, and sexual orientation. Identity has replaced merit. Equality of outcome is deemed more equitable than equal opportunity. Urban politicians, dependent on donations from teachers’ unions, refuse to offer school choice to their cities’ poorest residents. For too many, persistent and rising welfare benefits lead to dependency. Instead of two-parent families, it is said to “take a village” to raise a child.

 

Police are under attack and crime has risen. Our southern border is porous. Cities like San Francisco, Chicago, Baltimore, and Philadelphia have lost not only their charm but their livability, as stores are shuttered and the homeless defecate on streets. A sense of impending doom has descended on the nation’s young, as climate scaremongers say we face an existential crisis, if we persist in using gas stoves and do not drive EVs. Drug use is up, as are suicides, especially among the young. Teachers’ unions have become the most important financial backers of Democrat politicians, yet student scores keep declining, affecting most seriously the poorest in inner cities. Blacks are told to express their grievances, that their fate is to be a victim, dependent on government largesse. Whites are told they are oppressors. The ladder that allows for ascension up the socio-economic steps has been yanked away by the political left. 

 

One consequence has been a decline in birthrates, which, more than climate change, pandemics, or AI, threatens mankind. Exponential economic growth depends upon exponential growth in the labor force. Fertility rates below 2.1, needed to maintain a population, mean an aging and, ultimately, a declining population. Some of that can be made up with immigrants, but, as Malcolm Collins wrote recently in The Telegraph, those in the U.S. “…often don’t realize the pools from which they draw (Central America, South America, and the Caribbean) collectively fell below the sustainable rate in 2019.” This is a problem for the West. Mr. Collins added: “Western countries are like farmers draining an evaporating pool to keep their crops healthy, and ignoring the situation because the pond is unlikely to totally dry up in their lifetimes.”

 

Government, not individual initiative, is seen as the answer to all problems. “We have to paint a dark, bad picture because that’s what justifies more spending,” said Robert Doar, who once ran social services for Mayor Michael Bloomberg, in an interview in last weekend’s The Wall Street Journal. Joe Biden projects the image of a doddering old man. Donald Trump, a man I supported twice for President, looks backward, focused on retribution, rather than a brighter future. E Pluribus Unum, the 1782 motto of the United States, is no longer applicable, replaced by the metaphor of a salad bowl, which emphasizes differences, rather than what we have in common. 

 

But the future is never clear. Habits and attitudes change. What climate fear mongers overlook is the ability of species to adapt, and for the Earth to adjust through, for example, what is known as the Iris Effect, which exerts “a significant negative climate feedback that stabilizes tropical temperatures and limits climate sensitivity.” This according to Richard Lindzen and Yong-Sang Choi, writing in the February 2022 issue of Asia-Pacific Journal of Atmospheric Sciences. They were quoted by Andy Kessler in the June 5, 2023 issue of The Wall Street Journal. Cyanobacteria, one of the earliest known forms of life, has been around, according to microbiologists, for 3.5 billion years. Ctenophores date back 700 million years, Sponges 600 million years, Horseshoe Crabs and the Elephant Shark over 400 million years. Man first evolved in Africa between two and six million years ago, during the late Cenozoic Era. He has lived through myriad temperature changes. Adaption, not scare tactics, should be part of any environmental plan.

 

Man is almost infinitely resourceful and adaptive. He is aspirant, and, when allowed by the political system under which he lives, he is creative, and innovative. In the immediate aftermath of World War I, in the depths of the 1930s Depression, in the early days of World War II, at the 1968 Democratic National Convention, in the jungles of Vietnam, after the attack on 9/11, and during the credit crisis of 2008-9, it was hard to be confident of America’s future. But those earlier periods – the two decades after World War II and the 1980s-1990s – showed what was possible. We need leaders today who are honest about our challenges, not issuing canards to deflect the truth. We need leaders who, unafraid to acknowledge our faults, emphasize our goodness. We need leaders who offer hope, not fear. At the start of the Civil War, but in a posthumously published poem, Emily Dickinson wrote; “Hope is the thing with feathers that perches in the soul/ And sings the tune without the words and never stops at all.”

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, January 23, 2022

Essay from Essex - "Ancestry"

 


 

Sydney M. Williams

 

Essay from Essex

“Ancestry”

January 23, 2022

 

“Everything, from when and where we are born to when and how we die,

is out of our hands. All we have to decide is what to do with the time that is given us.”

                                                                                                                                J.R.R. Tolkien (1892-1973)

                                                                                                                                The Fellowship of the Ring, 1954

 

The pandemic prompted an interest in genealogy, made easier because of the internet and with companies like Ancestry.com, 23andMe.com and MyHeritage.com. This interest was not so much about deifying one’s ancestors, as was common in preliterate societies, it was more about learning of inherited diseases. Nevertheless, those companies saw their businesses double over the past two years, and Ancestry.com, a billion-dollar revenue company, was sold to Blackstone for $4.7 billion in December 2020.

 

Curiosity about one’s ancestors also played a role. We inherit traits from those who came before us, and gene and DNA technology have made tracing one’s ancestors easier. As well, I have long been fascinated by the math of evolution. Everyone descends from two people. Assuming three generations per hundred years, looking back a thousand years to the Norman invasion of England, a child born today would descend from 536,870,912 twenty-seven great grandparents. With the population of the world in 1066 estimated to be about 340,000,000 how would that be possible? The only answer is that we have common ancestors. My parents, for example, were fifth cousins, both descended from William Greenleaf (1725-1803) and Mary Brown Greenleaf (1728-1807). For most of human history populations lived in low-density rural areas. In 1790, 90% of Americans lived and worked on farms. Spouses were generally neighbors and likely to be 2nd, 3rd or 4th cousins. It was 1920, three hundred years after the first Pilgrims landed in Plymouth, before more Americans lived in cities than in the country, a consequence of the Industrial Revolution and a surge in immigrants during the last half of the 19th Century and the first couple of decades in the 20th.

 

Nevertheless, with so many preceding us, we each carry the genes of some fascinating forebearers, who should be judged by the moral standards of their time, or else we would disown many of them. At the time of the Civil War, roughly 10% of the U.S. population was comprised of slaves – about 3.1 million. Slavery was not novel to the U.S. While inhuman, it had been ubiquitous throughout most of human history. It appears in the Bible and in the Code of Hammurabi. It was pervasive in classical Greece and in republican and imperial Rome. It persisted in Europe, the Americas, Africa and Asia and still exists in parts of the world. Helen Keller, in The Story of My Life, perhaps quoting Plato or Socrates, wrote: “There is no king who has not had a slave among his ancestors, and no slave who has not had a king among his.”

 

At the time of the Civil War, almost all slaves in the United States lived in the south. Seventy-five percent of southerners owned no slaves, while 1,733 families owned more than a hundred each. Among those families were one set of my eight two-greats grandparents in rural Tennessee, about 30 miles north of Nashville. In 1860, according to the Tennessee Encyclopedia, the farm contained about 13,000 acres, had 274 slaves. It was the largest grower of dark fire-cured tobacco in the U. S.

 

While some of the letters and papers stayed with the family, most of the original documents from Wessyngton, as the farm was called, were donated to the Tennessee State Library and Archives in Nashville. The best history of the place was written by a descendant of some of those slaves, John F. Baker, Jr. of Springfield, Tennessee in 2009: The Washingtons of Wessyngton Plantation. In this book, which Kirkus Reviews calls “an enriching, deeply personal history,” he traces his ancestry. One set of Mr. Baker’s two-greats grandparents, Emanuel and Hennie Washington, had been born into slavery at Wessyngton. An 1891 photograph of them, with their two sons, adorns the cover of his book. A copy of the same photograph hangs in our apartment in Essex, Connecticut. Wessyngton was founded by a three-greats grandfather, Joseph Washington in 1796, the year Tennessee became a state. With John Baker and Stanley Rose (a third cousin) as the impetus, a Wessyngton Memorial Monument was dedicated in October 2015 listing the names of over 200 slaves known to have been buried there. As a youngster, I visited Wessyngton when two of my maternal grandmother’s siblings lived on the farm. In the early 1980s, our oldest son spent two summers working in the tobacco fields.

 

Another story that I used to hear told was of Richard the “Indian Killer.” Richard Hunnewell, born about 1645 in Devonshire, England and migrated to Scarborough, Maine (then part of Massachusetts colony). His wife and one child were killed in an Indian raid, and he was killed by Indians at Massacre Pond in 1703. However, there were several Richard Hunnewells and records are confusing. The Richard from whom I believe I descend lived a more prosaic life, as a mason and bricklayer in Charlestown, Massachusetts. 

 

There are other nuggets tucked into the recesses of my ancestry, as there are with everyone. Asa Messer (1769-1836) was a three-greats grandfather on my father’s side. In 1804 he became president of Brown University, the same year the college took its present name. He served until 1826, when his belief in Unitarianism created concern from some of the Congregational trustees. My middle name comes from him. A four-greats grandfather on my mother’s side was Noah Webster (1758-1843) of dictionary fame. A great-grandfather, Joseph Edwin Washington (1851-1915), spent ten years as a Democrat Congressman from Tennessee. Edward Augustus Silsbee (1826-1900) was a great uncle of my paternal grandmother. He was a bachelor sea captain who became fascinated with the poet Percy Bysshe Shelley, and was the inspiration for Henry James’ novelette, The Aspern Papers. Our second son was named for him. Gideon Welles (1802-1878), nicknamed “Father Neptune” and Lincoln’s Secretary of the Navy during the Civil War, was one of my great great-grandmother’s (Isabelle Welles Hunnewell – 1812-1888) second or third cousins. A framed photograph depicts my maternal grandmother with her godfather, Fitzhugh Lee (1835-1905), no relation but a nephew of Robert E. Lee. Through the Webster side of my family, we trace our ancestry to William Bradford of the Mayflower. However, if you think that is bragging, the General Society of Mayflower Descendants estimates there are 35 million living descendants of those 100 or so people who arrived in Plymouth, Massachusetts on November 11, 1620.  

 

Stories of ancestors provide entertainment, and they make history more interesting, as we associate historic events with those from whom we descend. They help us realize how far we have come. Have you wondered what kind of a life your great grandmother lived, or what made your ancestors leave their home country to come to an unknown new world? We all have interesting forebearers among the hundreds of thousands from whom we descend. Among them are likely kings and slaves, as well as ruffians and preachers. We cannot change them or the times in which we lived. But we should know something of them.

 

It is Gandalf’s advice, quoted in the rubric that heads this essay, that I find inspirational. There are aspects of our selves we cannot change – the color of our eyes, our height or gender. But we were all given life, which is a miracle when one considers the odds against being born. It is how we conduct ourselves and what we do with the life given us that should be our focus. Two hundred years from now some descendant might query about his or her ancestors. No descendant of mine will remember me for my accomplishments. I will have no Wikipedia page. But I hope to be remembered for having lived honorably. 

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, May 12, 2021

"Rsik"

 


 

Sydney M. Williams

www.swtotd.blogspot.com

 

Thought of the Day

“Risk”

May 12, 2021

 

“If no one ever took risks, Michelangelo would have painted the Sistine floor.”

                                                                                                                                                Neil Simon (1927-2018)

 

Recently, while walking around Boone Hall Plantation and Gardens, in Mount Pleasant, South Carolina, my son and his family came across an alligator. They watched it, but wisely did not approach it. Risk aversion can be a wise decision. Seth Klarman, president of Baupost Group once wrote: “In contrast to speculators preoccupation with rapid gains, value investors demonstrate risk aversion by trying to avoid loss.” But as Paul Singer, another wise investor, remarked regarding the role of government in our economy: “…the forces of risk aversion and constant conflict serve to stultify and narrow the range of ideas up for debate.” We must walk the line, avoiding obvious risks, but being unafraid to speak out and take risks. “Security,” wrote Helen Keller, “is mostly a superstition. Life is either a daring adventure or nothing.” Eleanor Roosevelt’s advice: “Do one thing every day that scares you.”

 

Every day we make hundreds, perhaps thousands, of decisions that involve risk. Many, if not most, are subconscious – standing on one leg to put on our trousers, reaching high for a coffee cup, ignoring the slippery spot on the floor, crossing a street. Do we take the short cut over the mountain, or the longer but safer route? Determining risk is a measurement of success versus failure. In investing, businesses calculate the potential for profit against the possibility of loss, which is why the Biden Administration’s proposal to strip Pfizer, Moderna and Johnson and Johnson of their patent protections for COVID-19 vaccines add risk to all future investments drug companies make in research. If patent protection can be breached, what does that say to those who invest in scientific research, and to those who risk everything in the creative arts, all of which are supposed to be protected by intellectual property rights? 

 

At a time when hesitancy has caused the number of daily vaccinations to decline by almost two thirds, the President, who was fully vaccinated in December, should not have worn a mask when outside and not surrounded by others. Yet he did just that last week when he and his wife left Jimmy and Roslyn Carter’s home. The message: the vaccine does not assure safety. When the FDA ordered Emergent BioSolutions to suspend production of Johnson & Johnson’s single dose vaccine because seven out of seven million vaccinated patients developed life-threatening blood clots, was the risk worth the cost of scaring people off being vaccinated? On Jimmy Kimmel’s show last week, Dr. Anthony Fauci said he was frustrated that nearly 26% of the population won’t get the vaccine, yet he said he would not dine in an indoor restaurant, despite being fully vaccinated. What kind of a message was he sending? Being vaccinated will not eliminate all risk of getting COVID-19, but it greatly reduces it. Responsible leaders lead, not inject fear.

 

While COVID-19 made us more risk averse health-wise, we have become more precipitate in our willingness to take financial risk. Financial and commodity markets soared over the past twelve months, especially products like crypto currencies, with the price of Bitcoins having risen over 500% from $8815.23 on May 12, 2020, to $56,871 yesterday. Given its volatility, is it possible to gauge what a cup of coffee or a tank of gas will cost in Bitcoins tomorrow or in two months? Over the past year, the value of Tesla stock has risen 280%, from $161.88 to $617.20 yesterday. While the company’s growth rate has been phenomenal, has not risk for the investor increased with a price to earnings ratio over 500 times? During that same time, the Dow Jones Industrial Average rose 44%%, from 23,764.78 a year ago to 34,269.16 yesterday. Over the past year, copper prices are up 100% and wheat is up 22%, suggesting inflation may well be in our future. Stock markets reflect future economic growth and imply a discounted rate for forecasted earning. US GDP is forecast to be up 6.5% in 2021 and 3.1% in 2022. Based on consensus earnings estimates, the S&P 500 is selling at 22X 2021 earnings and 19X 2022 earnings. How does one measure risk in valuations and the likelihood that forecasted earnings will be correct? With Treasury borrowing record amounts, what interest rate should be used in discounting future earnings? In the May 1, 2021 issue of The Credit Strategist, Michael Lewitt wrote: “We are in a bubble because valuations of virtually every asset class are untethered from economic fundamentals.” However, the decision to sell assumes one can successfully time markets. But, as Laszlo Birinyi in his May Market Commentary wrote, “…since 2009 [with the S&P 500 up 280%], there have been 3,082 trading days, but just 60 of those days have accounted for the entire gain in the market.” Who among us is that astute?

 

Government believes it can remove risk in people’s lives and achieve equity, by focusing on equality of outcomes, rather than equal opportunities. But does not an anti-meritocratic, government-led diversity policy risk unintended results? Historically, individuals were free to make choices, assume responsibility, and then reap the benefits or suffer the consequences of their decision. In the Republican response to President Biden’s State of the Union address two weeks ago, Senator Tim Scott (R-SC) made the point: “The beauty of the American Dream is that families get to define it for themselves.” In mediating risk, will the opportunity to better one’s life be diminished? To live freely is to accept risk. When does cradle-to-grave security interfere with the freedom to create individual opportunities?

 

We should not live in fear, yet a well-intentioned government intent on protecting us makes people Eloi-like. Schools and colleges have created an environment – now passed on to businesses, government offices, Hollywood and the media – where to challenge the consensus is to risk retribution or worse. Whites are told to view themselves as oppressors, to atone for the past sin of black slavery. To disagree is to risk condemnation. To question whether a trans woman should compete in female sports is to risk rebuke. To question Critical Race Theory, which itself is discriminatory, is to be tagged a racist. Is aversion to risk in expressing opinions what we want for our children, students, employees and citizens?

 

One result of this preference for a collective emphasis on conformity and government-ensured safety over freedom and personal choice has been a rise in pessimism for the future. A Gallop Poll last year found that pride in the U.S. is the lowest in two decades. A Pew Research survey in 2019 noted that by 2050 the U.S. will be worse off in many ways, including the national debt, political division and the cost of health care. That pessimism has manifested itself in record low fertility rates. For 2020, according to data from the CDC released last week, the total fertility rate (TFR) was 1.64, the lowest since tracking began in the 1930s. (A TFR of 2.1 is needed for a population to remain constant.) This was not simply a response to COVID-19, as total births have been declining since 2007, the last year the TFR was above replacement. By 2050, it is expected that the number of people over 65 will exceed those under 18. People who fear the future don’t have children. How do we recover the optimism of our Founders who risked so much?

 

Fifty-seven years ago, Caroline and I took a risk in getting married. I had done my military service but was still in college, with no idea as to how I would make a living. Despite a future we could not see, we had faith in each other. The road ahead held challenges and included potholes, but we believed in ourselves and in the Country in which we were blessed to be born, raised and where we lived. So, my advice: Be not afraid to take risks, just not foolish ones, like petting an alligator. “In a world that is changing really quickly,” said Mark Zuckerberg, “the only strategy that is guaranteed to fail is not taking risks.” Margaret Thatcher once wrote: “Discipline yourself to do what you know is right and important, although difficult. It is the high road to pride, self-esteem and personal satisfaction.” My advice: Be self-reliant, responsible, and accountable. Do not let government dictate choices or deter you from taking sensible risks to improve your lot. Look ahead, optimistically, with clear, wide-open eyes.

Labels: , , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, April 11, 2020

"Risks and COVID-19"

Sydney M. Williams
www.swtotd.blogspot.com

Thought of the Day
“Risks and COVID-19”
April 11, 2020

“There is freedom waiting for you.
On the breezes of the sky.
And you ask. What if I fall?
Oh, but my darling,
What if you fly?”
                                                                                    Erin Henson (1981-)
                                                                                    Artist, Designer, Poet

Most decisions we make involve some measure of risk. Generally, the consideration is fleeting. Do I take the stairs and risk falling, or the elevator and risk it breaking down? At times, the choice is more absolute: Do I take the double-black diamond with moguls, or do I go around on the bunny trail? Sometimes the odds are important: Is my need to cross the street against traffic so great that the attempt should be made despite oncoming traffic? Risk is ubiquitous. It is embedded in the friends we make, where we go to college, what job we take and in our choice of a marriage partner – a risk my wife and I took fifty-six years ago today. A wise friend used to say that he was never upset with mistakes he had made but was troubled by risks he never took. Risks vary depending on what we do. To a soldier in combat, risks have different consequences than the ones we encounter daily. In his 1916 collection of poems, Mountain Interval, Robert Frost included “The Road Not Taken.” At a fork in the road a traveler pauses, knowing he cannot walk down both paths, so chooses “the one less traveled by…”  The reader never knows whether the choice was a good one or not, only that it “has made all the difference.” As well, progress is impossible without risk. A baserunner cannot steal second without taking his foot off first. Neither can we avoid risk. “Security,” as Helen Keller once wrote, “is mostly a superstition.”

Risk is defined as the interaction with uncertainty, a measure of the probability of danger or loss, against safety or profit. In our daily lives, we try to mitigate risk. We are encouraged to look before we leap. Insurance companies employ actuaries to assess risk and calculate premiums. Investors use algorithms to quantify the risk of loss against the potential for gain. While these calculations are never perfect, they are Darwinian in that those who are best at measuring risk tend to be the most successful, what Joseph Schumpeter termed creative destruction in industries as they adapt to change.

Politicians employ risk to further agendas: we are told we will be overrun by illegal immigrants if we do not shut our borders; we are frightened into believing that anthropomorphic warming will destroy the planet, and that an ever-expanding population will lead to mass starvation. Now we have the health risk of COVID-19 that was first downplayed by professionals, the media and politicians, but which now dominates the news. As well, COVID-19 has created enormous economic risks.  

There is little question that COVID-19 is dangerous, especially for the elderly and those that have under-lying medical conditions, like asthma, lung diseases, heart conditions, diabetes, liver or chronic kidney disease. Given the game of blame, as to who missed the seriousness of the virus, it may be of value to review some of what was said and done about COVID-19, from when it first made its appearance – a timeline, if you will, but a list that does not pretend to be exhaustive; but it is indicative.

November 17, 2019 – On March 14, 2020, Jeanna Bryner, Editor-in-Chief of Life Science, quoting the South Morning China Post, reported that a “55-year-old individual from Hubei Province may have been the first person to have contacted COVID-19…That case dates back to November 17, 2019….That’s more than a month earlier than doctors noted cases in Wuhan, China, which is in Hubei Province.”

December 31, 2019 – The New York Times reported on April 7, 2020 that on December 31, 2019: “The Chinese government confirmed that health authorities were treating dozens of cases.”

January 14, 2020 – The World Health Organization (WHO) said: “Preliminary investigations conducted by the Chinese authorities have found no clear evidence of human-to-human transmission.”[1]

January 17, 2020 – The Centers for Disease Control (CDC) stated that, “based on current information, the risk from 2019-nCoV to the American public is currently deemed to be low.” The CDC and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) announced that American citizens returning from travel-restricted countries were being rerouted to specific airports where they would be screened and isolated.

January 20, 2020 – Japan, South Korea and Thailand reported their first cases of the novel coronavirus.

January 21-24, 2020 – World Economic Forum in Davos – attended by 3000 individuals from 117 countries, including 53 heads of state. China sent a large delegation, though Xi Jinping did not attend.  

January 21, 2020 – The first case of coronavirus in the United States was reported of a man who had traveled from Wuhan, China.

January 22, 2020 – President Trump, in response to a question regarding COVD-19: “We have it totally under control; it is one person, coming in from China.”  On that same day, Senator Tom Cotton (R-AR), a hawk on China, sent a letter to Alexander Azar, Secretary of Health and Human (HHS), encouraging the Administration to consider banning travel between China and the U.S.

January 24, 2020 – The CDC confirms the second U.S. case of coronavirus, adding, “based on what we know right now, the immediate risk to Americans remains low.”

January 28, 2020 – The WHO, following a meeting between WHO Director-General Dr. Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus and Chinese President Xi Jinping, issued a release: “The WHO delegation highly appreciated the actions China has implemented in response to the outbreak, its speed in identifying the virus and openness in sharing information with WHO and other countries.”

January 29, 2020 – According to an April 5th article in the New York Times by Maggie Haberman, Peter Navarro, President Trump’s trade advisor, warned the White House on January 29th that coronavirus could “cost the Country trillions of dollars and put millions of Americans at risk of illness or death.”

January 30, 2020 – The WHO declared a global health emergency of international concern. The CDC confirmed publicly for the first time the person-to-person spread of coronavirus. That same day President Trump created the White House Coronavirus Task Force to coordinate all efforts, with HHS Secretary Alexander Azar as chair.

January 31, 2020 – President Trump declared coronavirus a U.S. public health emergency and issued a ban on travel between the United States and China. On that same day, Joe Biden criticized the President for the travel ban: “This is no time for Donald Trump’s record of hysteria and xenophobia.”

February 4, 2020 – The White House directed the FDA (The U.S. Food and Drug Administration) to step up coronavirus diagnostic testing procedures.

February 5, 2020 – The CDC issued a statement: “While we continue to believe the immediate risk of 2019nCoV exposure to the general public is low, CDC is undertaking measures to help keep that risk low.”

February 7, 2020 – New York City Health Commissioner Oxiris Barbot told a TV interviewer, “I want to be clear, this is about a virus, not a group of people. There is no excuse for anyone to discriminate or stigmatize people of Asian heritage. We are here today to urge all New Yorkers to continue to live their lives as usual.”

February 10, 2020 – New York’s Mayor Bill de Blasio was interviewed on MSNBC: “If you are under 50 and you’re healthy, which is most New Yorkers, there’s very little threat here. This disease, even if you were to get it, basically acts like a common cold or flu. And transmission is not that easy.”

                  February 18, 2020 – The CDC reaffirmed, “The risk to Americans from coronavirus is low.”
February 20, 2020 – The White House raised travel warnings to their highest level for Japan and South Korea.
February 24, 2020 – Nancy Pelosi toured San Francisco’s Chinatown, urging people to come along, mingle and shake hands with residents.
            February 26, 2020 – The first case of suspected local transmission in the United States was announced by the CDC. On that same day, President Trump replaced Mr. Azar as head of the corona task force with Vice President Michael Pence.
            February 27, 2020 – Vice President Pence named Dr. Deborah Birx to serve as the White House Coronavirus Response Coordinator.
            February 29, 2020 – The first death in the U.S. from coronavirus was recorded in the U.S. On the same day, President Trump halted travel to and from Iran.
            March 11, 2020 – The WHO declared coronavirus a worldwide pandemic.
            March 12, 2020 – President Trump imposed travel restrictions with Europe.
            March 13, 2020 – President Trump declared coronavirus a national emergency.
            March 14, 2020 – The White House extended travel bans to the United Kingdom.
All the incidents mentioned above reflect risks that were either political, reputational or both. People on both sides of the aisle can find the fodder to satisfy claims of neglect or worse. But should that be our pursuit as we face the twin crises of a pandemic and a collapsed economy? As someone once said (or should have if they did not), “democracy is a slow process of stumbling to the right decision, instead of going straight forward to the wrong one.” Unlike dictatorships, democracies move slowly, as they listen to multiple voices and encourage debate. Japanese Admiral Isoroku Yamamoto, after Pearl Harbor, is alleged to have said: “I fear we have awakened a sleeping giant and filled him with a terrible resolve.” They had. Was the President late in declaring a health emergency, or did the fault lie with the WHO and the CDC who downplayed its seriousness? Should Democrats have been pursuing a feckless impeachment when the coronavirus was invading our shores? Early on, with the exception of Senator Tom Cotton and Secretary Alexander Azar no one in Washington appeared to take seriously what became a pandemic. Why? Was it because of a deceitful China or a compromised WHO? Was it because Washington and the media were otherwise engaged? In a recent Wall Street Journal op-ed, Holman Jenkins concluded: “Many things are worth doing; many risks are worth taking, and many are worth avoiding. It would be great to have more clear thinking about which is which in our current crisis.”  But that is the problem with forecasts. We deal with things as they are. “The future,” as the song goes, “is not ours to see.” At the moment the focus should be on helping the sick, finding cures and righting the economy. There will come a time to disinter the past and place blame where it belongs: who underplayed and who overplayed the risks of COVID-19?
With the benefit of hindsight, it is easy to point out missed signs, like the concern of Senator Cotton on January 22 or the warnings from Secretary Azar a week later. But it wasn’t until January 30 that the WHO and the CDC elevated coronavirus to a health emergency of international concern. The next day, the President declared COVID-19 a U.S. public health emergency and banned flights from China. So, should he have listened to two men, accomplished in their fields but neither a doctor, or should he have heeded the scientists and doctors at the CDC and the WHO? Keep in mind, the President had to navigate the ship of state through the Charybdis of a public panic and the Scylla of ignoring an unknown health threat. He chose a middle course. Given what we now know about the failure of a compromised WHO and a depleted Strategic National Stockpile of drugs and medical equipment, it appears, at least to me, that he chose well. But risks continue to propagate. The United States has lost 10% of its workforce in three weeks, a rate of decline faster than during the Great Depression. The President now faces a challenge – how to restart a twenty-two trillion-dollar economy, without reigniting the deadly virus.
It has been three months since coronavirus struck our nation. As a Country, we have rallied. It appears that social distancing, self-isolation and commonsense hygiene are working, and that the worse may soon be over – that the light at the end of the tunnel may not be a freight train barreling toward us, but the light of resurrection, appropriate in this time of Passover and Easter. But there remain risks our leaders must take – How to restart this economy from the somnolence of a six-to-eight-week shutdown? How to pay back the two to four trillion dollars borrowed to save businesses and jobs? This will require more choices, decisions (and risks) for the politicians who lead. We are in untraveled territory. COVID-19 has not been eviscerated. Re-starting the economic engine will not be easy. Money is not free, and we all know it is the private sector that generates the income the public sector spends. Voters in November will elect the individual they believe best suited to lead us toward a healthy, economic revival.    






[1] Dates, not otherwise identified, come from a March 31, 2020 report by Cleta Mitchell in The Federalist. She is a partner in the Washington, D.C. law office of Foley and Lardner

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,