Tuesday, November 19, 2024

"Who Else Besides Trump?"

  

Sydney M. Williams

www.swtotd.blogspot.com

 

Thought of the Day

“Who Else Besides Trump?”

November 19, 2024

 

“Let me tell you, you take on the intelligence community,

they have six ways from Sunday at getting back at you.”

                                                                                               Senator Charles Schumer

                                                                                               The Rachel Maddow Show on MSNBC

                                                                                               January 3, 2017

 

“Too much power has been delegated to unaccountable bureaucrats.

Undoing this is necessary to restore American greatness – but

fraught with risk. The unelected elite are powerful and fight dirty.”

                                                                                                Liz Truss

                                                                                                Prime Minister, Great Britain, 2022

                                                                                                The Wall Street Journal, November 13, 2024

 

The paradox in Senator Schumer’s statement – a statement unchallenged by Ms. Maddow – is that he admitted to (and would have agreed with) Ms. Truss’s words written five years later – that unelected, unaccountable bureaucrats exert unacceptable power over our nation’s most powerful people, let alone the rest of us. Neither he nor Ms. Maddow acknowledged the irony embedded in their exchange.  

 

……………………………………………………………….

 

As I wrote on November 6, I felt relief, not joy, with the election’s verdict. But as my wife and I spent six days driving around Pennsylvania and Virginia visiting grandchildren, I thought of the election and its consequences. And I concluded that the growing power of the state and its threat to individual freedom has become so powerful that a traditional Republican candidate might not be willing to confront such an oppressive force – that it would take an individual unafraid to incur the wrath of the administrative state. 

 

There is no question that a government that looks after 335 million people needs a professional bureaucracy. The President and the Executive Branch appoint roughly 4,000 individuals, a tiny fraction of the two million federal civilian employees. The Hatch Act, passed in 1939, prohibits partisan political activity among civilian employees in the executive branch of the Federal and District of Columbia Governments, even as it excludes those Presidential appointees whose jobs depend on Senate confirmation. Nevertheless, violations of the Hatch Act have become rampant in recent years, especially in intelligence agencies and within the Justice Department, as “lawfare” was waged against Mr. Trump and some of his backers.

 

It is, though, the natural instinct of people to defend their jobs, to expand their bureaucracies; it is how they personally advance. It is why slaying the dragon of government bureaucracies is so difficult. But unchecked government growth leads to inflation, bloat, bias, waste, and ultimately to either a government that collapses, or one that assumes dictatorial controls. That being an unpleasant prospect, some restrictions on that growth must be imposed, no matter how unpopular.

 

Is Mr. Trump the right man for the job? Obviously, the question is unanswerable. It is not that I am without concerns. Some of Mr. Trump’s nominations, especially former Florida Representative Matt Gaetz, I find troubling, as I do the possibility that he might use “recess appointments” to bring on board those who may not receive Senate confirmation. Adhering not only to the words of the Constitution, but also to its intent, is paramount to the survival of our Republic. However, when I weigh what Mr. Trump proposes versus what has happened overseas, at our border, to inflation, to crime in our cities, and to our culture, schools, and universities over the past few years, I side with those calling out, “Halt!”

 

…………………………………………………………………….

 

Mr. Trump does not satisfy the traits I seek in a friend. He is crude. His bluntness in public is rude. He is incapable of humility. He seems barren of humor, especially the ability to laugh at himself. He is not introspective, nor does he seem to have an interest in history, or even in political philosophy. I don’t understand his love affair with the three trillion-dollar cryptocurrency market, and I believe markets that size should be regulated. I wish he had nominated Nikki Haley and Mike Pompeo to be in his cabinet rather than the abrasive Matt Gaetz or the untested Pete Hegseth. But none of us get everything we wish.

 

Character is important, but that and my personal preferences are not necessarily the qualities we need in a political leader when we are drowning in debt, living with a collapsed border, and enduring an education system – the most expensive in the world – that has failed our youth, all at a time when cultural issues are more important to elements of the Democratic Party than defending the country’s citizens. The problems we face are not unique to the United States. Classical western liberalism is under threat, as western democracies seem to have forgotten that individual freedom needs defending against those who seek power, as exemplified by dictators in countries like China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea. Evil, as the Bible teaches us, is ever-present. The United States is not perfect as we all know, but its form of government, and the liberty it provides the individual, is unique in the annals of human history. It is a country that has benefitted from capitalism, that understands the critical nature of Adam Smith’s “invisible hand,” encourages entrepreneurship, a country that offers, not equality of outcomes but equal opportunities to those who have ability and aspiration. Trump is a fighter for those things he believes in, for working-class people – regardless of race, nationality, or gender – and for all those who love this country, warts and all.

 

Despite being harried by a media that hates him and hounded by political opponents who used the power of the state to try to destroy him, and opposed by bureaucrats who do whatever it takes to defend their turf, he never quits. He is tenacious. The media and his political enemies claim he wants to become a dictator, but they don’t listen to all that he says – if they understood his proposal for a Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) – they would realize he wants to limit the power of the state, to remove onerous regulations and to reduce the taxes that fund the leviathan that has become our federal government. Writing about DOGE in Saturday’s New York Sun, Newt Gingrich stated: “Unearthing what is wrong and discovering what could be right is the ultimate contribution of this project.” A smaller government, with power returned to the people, is the goal. Nevertheless, there are risks. Can Musk and Ramaswamy work their magic with DOGE, without disrupting the economy and/or financial markets?

 

Mr. Trump is not my ideal of a President, but I understand why history called him at this moment: Respect for the opinions of others, accountability and personal responsibility are traits needed but in short supply in the media and in our governing classes, as the world moves further into the 21st Century – a world that will never be free from enemies to democracy. Will Mr. Trump be up to the task of navigating these shoals? I don’t know, but I suspect it will take someone outside the slipstream of politics as usual. We need a course-correction – a secure border, increased defense spending, mutual respect, an assurance that the concept of personal responsibility is alive and well, and accounta

Labels: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Sunday, March 17, 2024

"A Few Short, Random Thoughts"


 

Sydney M. Williams

swtotd.blogspot.com

 

Thought of the Day

March 17, 2024

“A Few Short, Random Thoughts”

 

“Listen to your hunches, pay attention to your intuition, do not dismiss your random

thoughts, inspirations or ideas…They could be giving you the best advice you ever had.”

                                                                                                                Neale Donald Walsch (1943-)

                                                                                                                Conversations with God, Book 3, 1998

 

American values, which have been denigrated, evolved over two hundred years. It has become common to debase history and belittle capitalism, Certainly, one can find faults in both. One thing that is often forgotten is how rare have been revolutions that produced positive change. The French Revolution of 1789 eliminated a king and produced an Emperor. The Haiti slave rebellion of 1791 got rid of the French and eliminated slavery, but the nation has never had an honest and fair government. The Russian Revolution of 1917 exchanged autocratic Tsars for totalitarian Communists. Other examples: China in 1949, Cuba in 1959, and Iran in 1979. But the American revolution produced a government that evolved into the world’s fairest representative democracy. Capitalism, which creates winners and losers, is antithetical to today’s devotees of DEI, with its focus on equal outcomes. Yet, it is capitalism that encourages competition and offers choices to consumers. Free market capitalism has done more to lift people out of poverty than any other economic system. It provides people opportunities, to strive to do their best in whatever field they choose. 

 

A few other thoughts: 

 

  • Democracy – a form of government close to the center of a spectrum that stretches from anarchy to autocracy. It is not perfect, as Churchill said in a speech before the House of Commons on November 11, 1947: “…the worse form of government except for all those other forms that have been tried from time to time.” Our democracy is, as Abraham Lincoln said at Gettysburg on November 19, 1863, a “government of the people, by the people, for the people.” It is rare. Despite its visible success, according to ourworldindata.org, twice as many people live in “closed autocracies” as live in “liberal democracies.” Yet, we cannot forget that while our government is beneficent, dependency on government, unless it is absolutely necessary, leads to a loss of freedom. 

 

  • Capitalism/Climate/Environment – It was free-market capitalism that produced the Industrial Revolution, a revolution that defoliated forests, polluted rivers, and eroded the landscape. But it also raised living standards, gave people access to healthier diets, better housing and medicines, and cheaper goods. It did increase wealth for merchants and bankers, but while we complain today about income and wealth disparities, those differences are less than they were at the end of the 19th Century and substantially below what they were when the world was composed of a few kings and aristocrats and millions of serfs and slaves – and those wealth disparities are far less in capitalist societies than in totalitarian regimes like China, Russia, Iran, and North Korea. And it was capitalism that gave us the means to clean up the environment – our forests, rivers, and landscapes.

 

As for climate, there is little doubt that man affects its change. But the planet’s climate has been changing long before man arrived on the scene. During the Mesozoic Era, when dinosaurs roamed the earth 100 million years ago, the planet’s average temperature is estimated to have been forty-five degrees warmer than it is today. A few million years later, during the Pleistocene Era with its Ice Age, the earth’s temperature averaged fifty-three degrees colder than today. About ten thousand years ago, the climate became warm enough to begin to melt the Ice Age’s glaciers. 

 

When one cleanses the environment, one positively affects climate. Confronting climate change and improving the environment began to be addressed long before the advent of the EPA and John Kerry. As Bjorn Lomborg wrote recently in The Wall Street Journal: “The data show that climate-related deaths from droughts, storms, floods, and fires have declined by more than 97% over the past century.” We need to calculate costs – both societal and economic of climate-change measures – against expected benefits. While there is more we can do, we have come a long way. But governments should not use climate as an excuse to pick winners and losers. Adam Smith’s “invisible hand is fairer and better suited. In the meantime, governments, agencies, and the media should drop the hysteria.

 

  • Immigration – Common sense tells us that when a country’s birth rates fall below replacement and economic growth is still the goal it must raise birth rates or increase migration. When people are admitted legally, authorities know who has entered. When migrants enter illegally, they arrive unknown. In my opinion, we should increase the number of legal immigrants, simplify immigration laws, allow for more seasonal workers, and, at the same time, tighten the border against illegal and unwanted migration. The country needs new workers and consumers. 

 

  • Education – Thomas Jefferson believed that only educated citizens would allow the American experiment in self-government to succeed. We all know that women and blacks, despite education, were denied the right to vote in 1789. Nevertheless, his ideas were radical for the time. His founding of the University of Virginia in 1819 partially achieved his goal. Youth today should have an understanding and appreciation of what the founders accomplished: limited government of the people, consisting of three separate but equal branches – legislative, executive, and judicial, based on the rule of law. They should read the Declaration of Independence and the Constitution. They should be taught how rights have evolved, and they should know history, to understand how the nation’s values have also evolved over time. Youth needs a clear understanding of geography, math/economics, philosophy, science, and religion; they should develop a sense of decorum and personal responsibility, and they need to be able to articulately express themselves.

 

These short takes are not definitive or all-inclusive. I have neither the time nor the ability to make them so, and you do not have the time (or desire) to read what may be obvious and repetitive. But I worry that we have lost a sense of what it means to be an American, that our differences rather than our commonalities define who we are. To live in this country, with all its faults, is to live among the world’s most fortunate people. We must not be arrogant about our luck. We need to recognize that there may come a time, as it did for past generations, when it will be necessary to defend what we have. We should never forget the blessings of individual freedom, and the benefits of living in a free and democratic republic, amid free-market capitalism – all of which we inherited and which it is our duty to pass on to those who follow.


Labels: , , , , ,

Wednesday, March 22, 2023

"The Call of the Tribe," Mario Vargas Llosa

 I briefly met the author about a dozen years ago in Vienna, when I attended a colloquium hosted by the Liberty Fund of Indianapolis and the Hayek Institute of Vienna. I have no memory of what transpired, apart from being honored to meet someone I admired through his writings.

 

The Call of the Tribe eloquently expresses the importance of liberty, which we risk losing today to a state where political corruption has become common and government bureaucracy more powerful. The opening chapter alone is worth the price of the book.

 

Sydney M. Williams

 

Burrowing into Books

“The Call of the Tribe,” Mario Vargas Llosa 

March 22, 2023

 

“‘Spirit of the tribe.’ This is the term given by Karl Popper to the irrationality of

the primitive human being that nests in the most secret recesses of all civilized people,

for we have never completely overcome that yearning for the traditional world – 

the tribe – when men and women were still an inseparable part of the collective…”

                                                                                                                Mario Vargas Llosa (1936-)

The Call of the Tribe, 2023, English translation

 

Mario Vargas Llosa, born in Peru and a Nobel Prize winner for literature, is a journalist, novelist, and essayist. As he writes in the introduction, he conceived of a book on liberalism after having read what Edmund Wilson had done for socialism in To the Finland Station. This is a collection of essays on seven individuals who contributed to liberalism: Adam Smith, José Ortega y Gasset, Friedrich August von Hayek, Sir Karl Popper, Raymond Aron, Sir Isaiah Berlin, and Jean-François Revel. Six of the seven grew up in 20th Century Europe when freedom was threatened by both fascism and communism. 

 

As well, the author reveals his personal views. “Liberalism is a doctrine that does not have answers to everything, as Marxism purports to do, and it has a place for divergence and criticism around a small but unequivocal core set of convictions, for example that freedom is the supreme value; it is not divisible or fragmentary, but rather indivisible, and must be evident in every sphere – be it economic, political, social, or cultural – in a genuinely democratic society.” He writes that liberals are not anarchists, that they want a “strong and efficient state,” which “must guarantee freedom, public order, the respect for law, and equal opportunities.” But, as he writes: “Equality before the law and equality of opportunities do not mean equality of income, something no liberal would propose. For that would be possible only in a society run by an authoritarian government that would ‘equalize’ all citizens economically through an oppressive system, doing away with different individual capacities…This would imply the disappearance of the individual, subsumed into the tribe.”

 

The essays are chronological, based on the birth date of the subject. Adam Smith (1723-1790), while called ‘Father of Economics,’ was more interested in “how society functions.” Vargas Llosa writes: “He always thought of himself as a moralist and philosopher.” He quotes Smith: “No society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far greater part of the members are poor and miserable.” In writing of José Ortega y Gasset (1883-1890), The author notes of how he differs from Marx in the use of the word “mass,” a word which to Marx meant the proletariat, a social class with no significant ownership in the means of production. To Ortega the mass “is a group of individuals who have become deindividualized, who have stopped being freethinking human entities and have dissolved into an amalgam that thinks and acts for them, more through conditioned reflexes – emotions, instincts, passions – than through reason.”

 

We read that Friedrich August von Hayek (1899-1992) is one of three modern thinkers to whom he (Vargas Llosa) owes the most from a political perspective – the two others being Popper and Berlin. Vargas Llosa writes: “The great enemy of civilization is, for Hayek, constructivism or social engineering, which looks to develop intellectually an economic and political model and then implant it in reality, something that is only possible by force – violence that degenerates into dictatorship – and which has failed every time it has been attempted.” The notion of central planning – something we now see in the West – was detested by Hayek and Sir Karl Popper (1902-1994). Austrian born to a Jewish family that two generations earlier had converted to Protestantism, Popper saw first-hand how the call of the tribe (in the form of anti-Semitism) spread quickly in a society he thought so open: “Planning, taken to its logical conclusion, leads to the centralization of power….to the destruction of freedom and to totalitarian regimes…”

 

Raymond Aron (1905-1983) was “a dispassionate intellectual, with a penetrating but showy intelligence and a cold clear prose…” Like all of the individuals about whom Vargas Llosa writes, Aron grew up in an unstable Europe. He quotes him: “…the highest living standards have been achieved in states that have political democracy and a relative free economy.” “But,” Vargas Llosa adds, “this panorama does not justify optimism, because developed, democratic society is under threat today. Its main enemy is the state, an entity that is essentially voracious, oppressive, and bureaucratic…”

 

Isaiah Berlin (1909-1997), a Latvian educated in England, became a professor of social and political theory at Oxford. “Berlin’s liberalism consisted, above all, in the exercise of tolerance, in his constant endeavor to understand his ideological enemy…” Berlin is quoted: “I am bored by reading people who are allies…What is interesting is to read the enemy…” In writing about Jean-François Revel (1924-2006), a man who spent most of his life as a socialist, Vargas Llosa writes: “With his independence…and his systematic defense of freedom whenever it is threatened or diminished. Revel seems like an Albert Camus or a George Orwell for our times.” Like them, Revel was misunderstood by many of his compatriots.

 

It is the call of the tribe that concerns Mr. Llosa. The tribal spirit is “a source of nationalism [that] has, along with religious fanaticism, been responsible for the largest massacres in human history…In certain countries, and not just in the third world, this ‘call of the tribe,’ which democratic and liberal culture – ultimately, rationality – had sought to free us from, has reappeared in the form of charismatic leaders, under whom citizens revert to being a mass in thrall to a caudillo…Nothing has illustrated the return of the ‘tribe’ better than communism, under which sovereign individuals regress to being part of a mass submissive to the dictates of s leader…”

 

This is a short (276 pages) but important book, especially in today’s world of soundbites. At a time when dissent is increasingly disallowed, The Call of the Tribe is a paean to liberalism, to freedom. In writing of Hayek, he thinks of today: “Ideas that, for him, played such an important role in the life of free nations have deteriorated, and in the modern world images now have the prominence that ideas once had…screens have replaced books as the primary source of knowledge and information for what is called public opinion.”

 

How true. Once read, this book should remain on your shelves for reference and re-reading.

Labels: , , , , , , ,

Wednesday, June 22, 2022

"From Where Will Reason Come?"

 This is being sent at this time of day, because Nerds-to-Go just addressed a problem that Microsoft caused by downloading “New Outlook” last week, without including my contacts. I am now happily back on old outlook.

 

Yesterday I attended a meeting about Ukraine. Understandably, great concern was expressed for the people of that war-torn nation and anger directed at Mr. Putin. My sense as I walked away: We must be careful lest our compassion for the Ukrainian people, our hatred for Mr. Putin and our passion for the freedoms we enjoy disturb the delicate balance of a world with a plethora of nuclear weapons. For almost seventy-five years we have lived in a world where multiple countries are capable of blowing up the planet in a matter of minutes. We, and the generations that follow, will also have to live in such a world. That fact must always be behind the geo-political decisions we make.

 

Sydney M. Williams

www.swtotd.blogspot.com

 

Thought of the Day

“From Where Will Reason Come?”

June 22, 2022

 

“I do not feel obliged to believe that the same God who has endowed

us with sense, reason and intellect has intended us to forgo their use.”

                                                                                                                Galileo Galilei (1564-1642)

                                                                                                                Letter of the Grand Duchess of Tuscany, 1615

 

In an op-ed in a recent The Wall Street Journal, Ted Van Dyk, author of Heroes, Hacks and Fools: Memoirs from the Political Inside, wrote: “The country is desperate for pragmatic problem solving and at least an attempt by leaders to collaborate across partisan and ideological lines.” It is true. People are impossibly divided, and the effect is being felt among families and friends. It is unhealthy, individually and collectively for the nation. One consequence was the choices voters had in 2020 – On the right the polarizing figure of Donald Trump, who despite his accomplishments as President, has an insatiable ego and is overly sensitive to criticism, which make him unpalatable to many conservatives. On the left, Democrats nominated Joe Biden, a 77-year-old career politician with no notable achievements, but with noticeable cognitive challenges. Was that the best a nation of 330 million people could do? Questions need to be answered: Why has reason failed? Where does fault lie? Why are we in this place? What can be done? 

 

The fault, in my opinion, lies principally with politicians who thrive on a strategy employed by Julius Caesar, divide et impera, divide and rule, and by a media that has given up on reporting in favor of advocacy. It is easier for politicians to address the needs and wants of specific constituents than to discuss complex issues that affect us all. Such activity has led to divisive “identity politics” and away from the understanding that we are all, regardless of race, class or ethnicity, citizens of this republic and that we all have a stake in its continuance. The United States is unique among nations in that our ancestors came from every corner of the world. It is unique in its government forged out of a belief in individual freedom, a government – with its separation of powers, rule of law, and protection of private property – whose primary responsibility is to guarantee the freedoms enumerated in the Constitution. We have differences, as expected and as we should, but, as citizens of the United States, we have in common (or we should have) a reverence for this imperfect but rare nation. 

 

Perhaps it is the cynicism that comes with age, but I believe most politicians would prefer not to solve many of the problems we face – illegal immigration, gun legislation, climate change, healthcare and abortion. One might add education and election integrity. These are perennial issues, which when left undecided serve both sides, in that they inflame noisy partisans, the driving force behind both political parties, and who further divide us. 

 

The U.S. House Select Committee to Investigate the January 6 Attack is exhibit A. This is not a committee trying to understand what happened – Exactly what role did Mr. Trump play? Why did not advanced warnings of trouble prompt enhanced security? If this was an insurrection, why were there no firearms found on the rioters? Why did the committee not investigate the claim of New York Times reporter Matthew Rosenberg that “there were a ton of FBI informants amongst the people who attacked the Capital?” Why was an unarmed woman shot and killed as she entered a Capital window? What might be done to prevent a future occurrence? Will the committee investigate the rioting during the summer of 2020, which killed 35, injured 1,500 police officers and caused $1.3 billion in property damage? From the start, the committee was established to be a partisan hit job on Mr. Trump and his supporters, not a bi-partisan voyage of discovery. Ironically, the Committee’s shaming of Mr. Trump may well backfire on Democrats who seemed to have forgotten that a viable Mr. Trump is Republican’s biggest liability and Democrat’s greatest asset.

 

As Michael Barone pointed out in an interview in The Wall Street Journal, it was not too long ago that “Americans expressed great trust in their institutions and great belief and confidence in their leaders.” Mr. Barone suggests Watergate was “a historical watershed” that ended that trust. But no matter its origin and whether deserved or not, disillusionment in government has harmed the United States. I recall being in the Senate dining room for lunch in the early 1970s and seeing Democrats and Republicans dining together. It’s my understanding that rarely happens today. Political partisanship has destroyed friendships and disrupted families. Verlan Lewis and Hyrum Lewis argued in last weekend’s The Wall Street Journal that the problem is less about polarization around “fixed ideological poles” and more about hostility toward individuals. Regardless, questions remain. Why have we reached this impasse and what, if anything, can be done to end it? It seems to me that our best hope lies in education, a return to reason, traditional values and a revival of patriotism.

 

Amidst this anger, we appear to have forgotten that free-market capitalism, within a democratic context, has made Americans wealthier beyond the wildest imaginations of those who lived a hundred and two hundred years ago. Few young people in the U.S. appreciate the lifestyles they live compared to that of their forebearers. They have little appreciation for the political and economic systems that make their lives comfortable. Do they ever think of the magic of capitalism, that a loaf of bread can be brought to a supermarket shelf for only three dollars? It is Adam Smith’s invisible hand that guides the farmer, miller, baker, trucker and merchant to work together. 

 

Reason has been lost as time-tested traditions and customs have collapsed. The concept of national service disappeared with the abandonment of the military draft. The Pledge of Allegiance and the singing of God Bless America (written by Irving Berlin in 1938 as a peace song) are no longer public-school rituals. According to a 2015 Pew Research Center study, only 22% of children today are living with two parents, both in their first marriage. Fifty-four percent are living with a single parent. Church attendance (including that at mosques and synagogues), which was 73% in 1937 when Gallup first measured it and 70% in 2000, fell to 47% in 2021.

 

Too many public schools are more focused on woke issues, like gender identification and “saving the planet,” than on the basics of reading and math, or simply teaching students to think independently. Apart from Luxembourg, the United States spends more money per student than any other country, yet we rank 13 out of 79 countries on the PISA (Programme for International Student Assessment), behind countries like Estonia and Poland. In a financial literacy test, the U.S. ranked nine of eighteen. Teachers should be embarrassed; parents should be upset, and we should all be concerned.

 

In the 1960 movie Inherit the Wind, which was based on the 1925 Scopes Monkey, Spencer Tracy as Henry Drummond (Clarence Darrow) asks, rhetorically: If we do not use our brain to reason, “why did God plague us with the capacity to think?” “What other merit have we?” We need politicians and members of the media, to treat people as adults, to approach problems, not as ideological opportunities to push preferred agendas, but as issues that need resolution. In his Critique of Pure Reason (1781), Immanuel Kant wrote: “All our knowledge begins with the senses, proceeds then to understanding, and ends with reason. There is nothing higher than reason.” Politicians (and media types) appeal to emotion, especially personal vilification. Their focus should be on imparting wisdom, allowing reason to blossom. Instead, they bully opponents and the electorate into submission with emotion-ridden ideological tirades, and the press laps it up.

Labels: , , , , , , , , , ,

Saturday, April 23, 2022

"Challenges"

 Yesterday was the 50th anniversary of Earth Day, originally established to celebrate awareness of, and to help protect, our environment – still a message that resonates. Sadly, it has been usurped by politicians and other cranks who claim that climate change is caused solely by humans, like Al Gore, who used the issue to gain wealth and John Kerry, who uses it to maintain relevance.

 

Sydney M. Williams

www.swtotd.blogspot.com

 

Thought of the Day

“Challenges”

April 23, 2022

 

“If we want a society where truth can be pursued,

we need a system in which ideas can be expressed.”

                                                                                             Steven Pinker, Cognitive Psychologist, Harvard College

                                                                                             Phone interview with A.R. Hoffman, New York Sun

                                                                                              April 2022

 

In a letter to a friend in late 1777, after General Burgoyne’s loss at Saratoga, Adam Smith wrote: “There’s a great deal of ruin in a nation.” His point was that great nations can withstand defeats – that it takes a great deal of bungling to bring down a powerful and prosperous state. But he did not deny that nations, like empires, can and do collapse.

 

We face challenges, but is the United States confronting ruin that could imperil our way of life? In the April 11, 2022 issue of The Atlantic, Jonathon Haidt wrote an article titled “After Babel: How Social Media Dissolved the Mortar of Society and Made America Stupid.” “Something went terribly wrong, very suddenly. We were disoriented, unable to speak the same language or recognize the same truth. We are cut off from one another and from the past.” Mr. Haidt warned of abuses from social media, which he blamed for the lack of cohesiveness, civility and trust in society and in government, as well as being a risk to democracy. The answer, he believes, lies in three parts: “hardening” democratic institutions against extremist elements; providing more intense regulation of social media, and helping the next generation by letting children be children, encouraging more time for fun and less time on smart phones. While I agree with his suggestions about children, I have doubts as to the wisdom of “hardening” democratic institutions, and I am not a fan of more regulation. In addition, I was disappointed he did not spend more time on how social media impedes free speech, in legacy media, schools, universities and in board rooms

 

A world in a whirlwind needs an anchor to windward. For most of man’s history that was religion. Today, in the United States, just over 40% of Americans say religion plays an important role in their lives. In the past two hundred years, since the onset of Industrial Revolution, there have been unprecedented changes in the lives of our species. Life expectancy in 1800 was 43, about the same as it had been at the time of Christ. In the past two centuries, it has increased almost 100 percent, and the quality of our lives have improved in hundreds of ways: transportation, communication, agriculture, the environment, sanitation, education and healthcare. Consider improvements we take for granted – central heating, air conditioning, public transportation, on-line shopping and options in entertainment. Think of the knowledge we have access to today through the internet. For better and for worse, social media has been one of those changes. We must ask ourselves: Has innovation outstripped our species’ innate ability to adapt?

 

For thousands of years man could travel (on land) only on foot or by horse. Now there are an estimated one billion passenger cars serving a world-wide population of eight billion, and rockets take us into outer space. The world’s population has grown by a factor of eight since 1798 when Thomas Malthus published his theory that a geometric increase in population could not be sustained with an arithmetic increase in food supply. He was wrong on both counts. Birthrates declined and food production per acre increased. The average American lives longer, eats better and lives more comfortably than yesterday’s kings. Consider the changes in communication in just the past twenty years. Technological advancements have outpaced the ability of humans to evolve naturally, and religion, as a moral anchor, no longer plays the role it once did.

 

Social media challenges customs and traditions. But we also face other threats: The United States is a multiracial nation, yet we are condemned as being systemically racist by today’s progressives. In an April 18thopinion for americagreatness.com, Victor Davis Hanson asked of America: “Can its various tribes and races unite around the Constitution?” My answers: If left alone from interfering progressives they would, but not when a cult of “social justice” drives decisions at schools, colleges and businesses. And not when we are seen as a nation of victims and victimizers. Woke progressives divide us based on race, ethnicity and gender, but not on class. Individualism has been sacrificed on an altar of collectivism. A black NBA millionaire is oppressed, while a white auto mechanic is an oppressor. A transgender cable TV anchor is a victim, while a white, cisgender nursing home aide is a victimizer. Globally, a peace-loving Israeli farmer is an aggressor, while a teenage Palestinian terrorist is a victim. Woke political correctness, with its mandate for diversity, equality and inclusion, threatens democracies.

 

In my opinion, the biggest challenge we face are threats to speech. Free speech encourages debate, thus slows decisions, an irritant for an impatient world. Social media, like Twitter, acts as a conduit, rather than an open forum. Today’s technocrats resemble H.G. Wells’ Morlocks, in their desire for control and in limiting open discussion. Opposition to free speech originated on college campuses, where professors fear offending sensitive students and where administrators see their mission as the indoctrination of students into a woke ideology, rather than providing an open-minded, liberal education. In this milieu, conservatives have been censured or cancelled. Intolerant woke ideologies have advanced in mainstream media where reporters act as editorialists, and they have infiltrated corporations where fear for one’s job prevents questioning doctrines of social justice. In Washington, what is information to one politician is labeled misinformation by another. People are not stupid. Let them hear both sides and decide for themselves.

 

There is validity to the concerns expressed by Mr. Haidt in The Atlantic, as social media attracts extremists and dregs of society; it is addictive and harmful to the vulnerable young, and much of the information that flows through its portals is garbage. But the way to handle the problem is to help users differentiate between good information and bad, to help them understand both the positive and negative aspects of what they are reading and viewing. The best way to do that is to ensure a classical, liberal education, where youth are exposed to different ideas and opinions, where they learn through debate and discussion, and where they are taught rules of moral behavior that have withstood the test of time. Religion, meditation and tradition provide moorings in an ever-changing, restless world. They restrain behavior and act as a governor on technological changes that infuse our lives. The great value of free speech is that deliberation slows the process of change by making all participants consider the consequences of their decisions.

 

Is the challenge we face enough to bring ruin to our nation? I don’t pretend to know. I hope not, but I worry.

Labels: , , , ,

Sunday, May 16, 2021

"The Age of Acrimony," Jon Grinspan

 In a letter to a concerned John Sinclair, founder of Scotland’s Board of Agriculture, who had brought news of British General John Burgoyne’s surrender at Saratoga in October 1777, Adam Smith wrote: “There is a great deal of ruin in a nation.” He meant that countries are able to cope with disappointments, poor policies and bungling politicians. Britain lost the battle at Saratoga and the American Revolution, but they want on to create the greatest empire the world had ever known. In the second half of the 19th Century, the United States went through a trying time, just as we are today. It is worth remembering Adam Smith’s voice of calm in his reply to Mr. Sinclair.

 

Sydney M. Williams

www.swtotd.blogspot.com


Burrowing into Books

“The Age of Acrimony,” Jon Grinspan

May 16, 2021

“There is incredible variability in how we have used our democracy, with plenty

of room for ugliness without apocalypse, and for reform without utopia.”

                                                                                                                Jon Grinspan

                                                                                                                The Age of Acrimony, 2021

 

The preamble to the Constitution begins: “We the people of the United States in Order to form a more perfect Union…” The emphasis is on “more.” The Founders never claimed to have formed a “perfect” Union, but one better than those that then existed. Also, in providing a process to improve and adjust the Constitution amendments were permitted. In fact, the first ten amendments (the Bill of Rights) were ratified on December 15, 1791. In the subsequent 230 years, seventeen additional amendments have been ratified. Our democracy is not static; it adjusts, not easily but judiciously, as customs and behaviors change. Jon Grinspan has given us, who now live in a new age of political strife, a well-written – albeit brief – informative look at the fifty years following the Civil War – a time of political acrimony. 

 

The time span covered by Mr. Grinspan – 1865 to 1915 – begins with the assassination of Lincoln and a Country emerging from the Civil War; it ends with the United States having surpassed Britain as the world’s largest industrial power. He takes us through Reconstruction and how it petered out, with violence in the South against blacks and with the North having given up on the concept of equal rights. We travel through the “Gilded Age” when fortunes were made in railroads, mining, oil, steel, electricity, shipping, newspapers and finance, and when former farmhands, women and children were recruited to work in city sweat shops and factories, where they performed low-paying, mind-numbing (often dangerous) repetitive jobs. His story ends with the reforms of the “Progressive Era.” In the early post-Civil War period, the public wanted the entertainment that political campaigners provided: “They expected charisma and wit and the hottest-burning fuel of the era: political outrage.” During these fifty years, we saw eleven Presidents, high voter turnout and two Presidents assassinated, Garfield and McKinley. Voter turnout peaked in the election of 1896 at 79.5%. Twenty-eight years later it troughed at 48.8% in 1924. While Republicans dominated the White House during the fifty years covered by Mr. Grinspan, elections were always close. The only two Presidents to be elected with more than 53% of the popular vote during that period were Ulysses Grant in 1872 and Theodore Roosevelt in 1904. Presidential election winners in 1880,1884, 1888, 1892 and 1912 won with less than 50% of the popular vote.

 

The author employs the father-daughter team of William D. “Pig Iron” Kelley (1814-1890) and Florence Kelley (1859-1932) to guide us through the political history of that era. Will Kelley was a thirty-year Republican member of Congress from Philadelphia. He had been an abolitionist and was a supporter of tariffs, especially on pig iron, an intermediate product used in the manufacture of steel, products important to Pennsylvania’s economy. A self-made man and exceptional public speaker, he loved the heat of political battle: “These are terrible times for timid people.” Florence Kelley, as a young girl, devoured the books in her father’s library. She became a political activist and social reformer. She graduated from Cornell and studied under the German economist Friedrich Engels. While her father was a politician, Grinspan writes: “Florie was beginning to see the limits on American electoral politics as a solution to social problems…imagining a future unchecked by constituents.” She had grown up in a time when politics were prized but not governance. She preferred the concept of professional bureaucrats to run government, not elected officials. She fought against sweat shops, and she fought for a minimum wage, an eight-hour day and the rights of children. She founded the National Consumer League and was a co-founder of the NAACP.

 

One is tempted, in looking back from today’s rancorous political atmosphere, to acknowledge truth in the old saying that the more things change, the more they stay the same. But that is not correct, at least not in this instance. While both then and now were [and are] characterized by rapid commercial advancement and acrimonious politics, there are significant differences. Wealth gaps have narrowed, and college graduation rates have improved. In terms of wealth gaps, Mr. Grinspan quotes one source that claimed 5,000 people controlled 50% of the wealth in the 1880s, or one hundredth of one percent of the then population. Today, approximately one percent (3.3 million people) own 43% of the nation’s wealth. Theodore Roosevelt’s trust busting, the implementation of a federal income tax in 1913 and an estate tax in 1916 helped mitigate wealth inequalities. As for education, college graduates, as a percent of the population, have gone from two percent in 1900 to more than a third today. The 19th Amendment and the Civil Rights Acts of 1964 and 1965 greatly expanded voter rolls. On the darker side, however, unaccountable bureaucrats – those desired by Florence Kelley – have changed the nature of a government into one less responsive to the people.

 

Yet, one finishes Mr. Grinspan’s book with a sense of optimism. As the rubric above this essay suggests, our democracy is versatile. It has been, is now, and will be tested. It bends but does not easily break. Nevertheless, liberty is precious and must be guarded. Everything has its breaking point. All laws, rules and regulations present a tug-of-war between the rights of individuals versus the needs of society. It is the balance a democracy seeks. In a speech at the Wisconsin State Far in September 1859, Abraham Lincoln quoted the ancient adage attributed to a Persian monarch: “And this, too, shall pass away.” But he added that the saying was “not quite true.” He pointed out that it is the cultivation of the physical, moral and intellectual worlds within each of us that sets the course toward prosperity and happiness, in our quest for the “more perfect union.”  Lincoln’s point in his speech: It is only because of the efforts of individuals that the forward trajectory of democracy shall not pass away. Mr. Grinspan has provided a pertinent and providential history of our experiment with a democratic republic, during an acrimonious time.

Labels: , , , ,

Wednesday, May 5, 2021

"Biden - A Marionette?"

Writing this essay was not easy and took longer than most I have written. The subject is a sensitive one, but nonetheless important, and I have tried to be fair. But if my speculation is correct, it reflects a cynicism unique to our politics.

 

 

Sydney M. Williams

www.swtotd.blogspot.com

 

Thought of the Day

“Biden – A Marionette?”

May 5, 2021

 

“It is possible to be a puppet on a string without fully realizing it.”

                                                                                                                                Life is a Cocktail, 2017

Steven Redhead

                                                                                                                                Founder Life Coaching Systems

 

In February 2017, less than a month after he had taken office, Representative Earl Blumenauer (D-OR), in a floor speech, questioned Mr. Trump’s mental health. He was joined by Senator Al Franken (D-MN) and Representative Ted Lieu (D-CA). According to an article in The Hill on February 17, 2017, thirty-five psychiatrists, psychologists and social workers signed a letter to the New York Times that stated, “the grave emotional instability indicated by Mr. Trump’s speech and actions make him incapable of serving safely as president.” The American Psychiatric Association has long held that to render a professional opinion on a public figure one has not examined is unethical. However, that didn’t stop the thirty-five, none of whom had met with Mr. Trump. We now have a new President. While no gaggle of psychiatrists has weighed in on Mr. Biden, one wonders: Are the President’s cognitive abilities declining, as some have suggested? The truth is, we don’t know; but some, including me, are suspicious that age has taken its toll on the man.   

 

President Biden has been a stutterer since childhood. According to the National Stuttering Association, stuttering is a “neurological disorder that interferes with the production of speech.” It does not indicate a psychological disorder or mental deficiency. It does not suggest dementia, but neither does it preclude it. Dementia is a catch-all word to describe various symptoms of cognitive decline. Early manifestations would include forgetfulness and limits to social skills and reasoning. In 1988, Mr. Biden suffered two brain aneurysms, but there is no reason to believe they would lead to any form of dementia.

Like those eminent psychiatrists and psychologists who passed judgement on President Trump, my opinion regarding President Biden is empirical, not analytical, so accept my words with caution – a warning the Times did not offer. Yet, to publicly question Mr. Biden’s fitness for office is apparently off limits. In 2017, Republicans like Mike Simpson (R-ID) agreed that Mr. Trump exaggerated and made false statements, and that it is always fair to question any President’s judgements. Yet, there is a deafening silence from both sides of the aisle when it comes to questioning the mental well-being of President Biden. Why?

 

Why do I feel as I do? Mr. Biden spent thirty-six years in the nation’s most deliberative body – the U.S. Senate. He could be mean-spirited, as Robert Bork and Clarence Thomas came to learn, but he could also be a consensus builder. He campaigned as a moderate and unifier, yet he has governed by Executive Order, signing over sixty EOs in his first hundred days as President, more than double what Mr. Trump did and more than triple what Mr. Obama signed in his first hundred days.

 

During the campaign, Mr. Biden’s handlers kept a tight rein on him. Like 19th Century Presidential candidates who campaigned from their front porches, Mr. Biden communicated to the electorate from the basement of his home outside Wilmington, Delaware. In contrast with Mr. Trump who enjoys dueling with a Press that despises him, Mr. Biden, as President, has shunned the media that adores him, as they ask about his favorite ice cream or photograph him picking dandelions for his wife. In his first message to Congress, Mr. Biden spoke for an hour with no hint of senescence. Of course, he was speaking from a place he has called home for forty-four years, and he read from a teleprompter, as have all Presidents since President Eisenhower first used one sixty-seven years ago. While he stumbled rarely, his stance was wooden, without the relaxed appearance of a man who knows what he is saying. He lacked graciousness toward his political opponents, inconsistent with a message of unity.  There seems, to this observer, a disconnect between the words he now utters and those of a man who has been in Washington since 1973.

 

President Biden has been accused of many indiscretions: from plagiarizing to lying about his college record, from financial relations in Ukraine and China to behaving inappropriately with women. He can be impulsive. When a popular black radio host, Charlemagne the God, asked him how to respond to someone struggling to decide whether to support him or President Trump, Mr. Biden shot back: “If you have a problem figuring out whether to support me or Trump, then you ain’t black.” In 2018, when asked to comment on one of President Trump’s crude comments, he said he wished they were in high school, so he could take him out behind the gym and “beat the hell out of him.” But Mr. Biden was not a left-wing radical. The New York Times, on October 18, 2020, called him “a seventy-seven-year-old moderate.” Yet, as President, he has proposed a radical, left-wing agenda. On April 29, 2021, the New York Times, changing their tune, described Biden as seeking “a fundamental reorientation of the role of government not seen since the days of Lyndon Johnson’s Great Society and Roosevelt’s New Deal.” But is his radical agenda rational when the most states are in Republican control, when the Senate is split 50-50, and when Democrats’ majority in the House is the smallest since World War II? Has Mr. Biden undergone a transformation, or is something more insidious at work?

 

It makes one wonder: Who is in charge? The voters in November chose a candidate whom they thought was a moderate and who was not Donald Trump. They wanted the normality his campaign promised. So, I ask: Is he being manipulated to implement policies the voters did not choose? Has Mr. Biden become a marionette, acting on behalf of unknown handlers? I don’t propose to have an answer, but I believe it is a possibility we cannot overlook, and an issue that should concern us all. Adam Smith wrote that there is a “great deal of ruin in a nation,” by which he meant it takes a lot of bungling by political leaders to bring down a powerful and prosperous nation, but all free countries are vulnerable, as democracy is fragile and not all men and women are angels.

 

Peggy Noonan, in a column in last weekend’s Wall Street Journal, wrote that President Biden, unlike his three predecessors, is not “hated.” That seems true; but has the radical left taken advantage of a cognitively impaired President to advance an agenda rejected in last year’s Primaries? If this speculation has any merit, then we have experienced one of the most undemocratic, dastardly tricks ever played on our democracy, with mainstream media fully complicit.

Labels: , , , , , ,