Monday, May 22, 2017

"Comey's Firing - A 'Man Bites Dog' Story"

Sydney M. Williams
swtotd.blogspot.com

Thought of the Day
“Comey’s Firing – A ‘Man Bites Dog’ Story?”
May 22, 2017

“There are lots of reasons why an election like this is lost, [but] our analysis is that Comey’s
 letter raising doubts that were groundless, baseless, proven to be [sic], stopped our momentum.”
                                                                                                Hillary Clinton in a call to donors,
                                                                                                As reported in the NY Times, Nov. 15, 2016

It had been universally acknowledged that FBI Director James Comey over-played his hand last July when he, essentially, indicted Mrs. Clinton, but then exonerated her. In doing so, he acted as investigator, prosecutor, judge and jury. He did it again on October 28, when he re-opened the investigation. His meeting with the President regarding Mr. Flynn was the day after the latter had been fired. Then, with crocodile tears, he claimed to be “mildly nauseous” that he might have “swayed” the election; but, he assured us, he would do it all over again. He played first for the Left, and then for the Right. He may be a qualified investigator, but his power grab was reminiscent of J. Edgar Hoover.

When I first heard that he had been fired, I thought it a “dog bites man” story, something expected. However, the righteous indignation from the supercilious and hypocritical Left has turned it into a “man bites dog” story. Rarely have so many morally bereft politicians, along with their obsequious media accomplices, invoked so virtuously their vexations.

One could argue that the optics in Comey’s firing were bad. But when, with the press Mr. Trump has received, would have been a good time? Perhaps he could have alerted Congressional leaders as to his intentions? But surely that information would have leaked. Could he have prepared his staff, so that a replacement could have been named within a day or two? Perhaps. But, to Washington’s establishment, Mr. Trump is a pariah, an outcast who arrived at the White House without their help; and he belittles them – unforgivable sins for those who work along the banks of the Potomac.

Democrats have made much of the fact that the FBI is investigating possible “collusion” of the Trump team with the Russians. That investigation will go on regardless of Director Comey's presence. Four Congressional committees are looking into the same allegations, suggesting redundancies, especially since some investigations have been underway for almost a year, without any proof of “collusion.” The hiring of Robert Mueller should assuage members of the “Resistance,” though the process will be long and won’t necessarily find an answer. Delay, however, will be injurious to Republicans’ agenda.

This strategy of the Left entails risk for democracy. The goal is to render Mr. Trump rudderless, to cause him to resign or be impeached. They take pleasure in the effects their efforts have produced. Should they succeed, they will widen divisions. They will hurt institutions. My guess is they misinterpret the consequences of what they do. Thanks to Harry Reid and, now, Mitch McConnell, implementation of the “nuclear option” has already meant that political bipartisanship and reconciliation are less likely. Would a forced resignation of a duly elected President for political and retaliatory purposes help heal our wounds? I think not. It would aggravate them. It’s a perilous game they have chosen to play.

Democrats have ignored for years their loss of representation in state governments, a reflection of their failure to connect with mainstream voters. In their bid to compartmentalize citizens for political access, they have segregated us by race, socio-economic position, sex and religion. They have refused to face the real reasons for last November’s Electoral College loss: an anemic economic recovery, which left labor participation rates at four-year lows; the persistent growth in unpaid-for “entitlements;” an expansion of the bureaucratic state; an evisceration of our military, with a new and formidable enemy on the rise; the imposition of moral relativism on a people who believe in moral absolutes; the ignoring of “deplorables” – white, middle-class, hard-working Americans – and a fatally flawed candidate without moral compass. Democrats like Chuck Schumer, Nancy Pelosi and Elizabeth Warren, along with their editorialist buddies in the media and a few Republicans, hate Trump with a viciousness rarely seen, even in Washington.

Headlines in the Washington Post and the New York Times last Tuesday were that Trump had given away state secrets to the Russians. Reporters attributed the accusations to “unnamed sources,” putting rebuttals from Trump officials who were at the meeting deep into their columns. Was that fair and balanced? Excepting for one or two programs, television news has become a joke. Viewers seek confirmation of pre-determined beliefs, whether from the Left or the Right. But, what may be entertaining should not be mistaken as informative. Schools and colleges are not teaching students the principles of democracy. History is viewed through a lens of political correctness. Historical context is ignored, as we saw this week in New Orleans. Students are indoctrinated into liberal causes from an early age, something that should concern all Americans. While more Americans have been to college, fewer are educated.

It is the hypocrisy of those on the Left that appalls – those who speak with moral superiority, like Connecticut’s Senator Richard Blumenthal who lied about his military service in Vietnam, or Massachusetts Senator Elizabeth Warren who lied about her Indian heritage. How can these people pretend to be paragons of virtue as they tilt at Mr. Trump?

This is not a defense of Mr. Trump’s character. He is egotistical and erratic, and appears to be without humor. This is a condemnation of those who risk our democratic institutions – establishment types from Washington, the media and academia – because of a seminal dislike for a man who is not one of them; worse, a man who has contempt for them. From what I know of Mr. Trump, I would not choose him as a neighbor, any more than I would choose the publishers and editors of the New York Times and the Washington Post, or the talking heads on MSNBC or CNN. They are all too smug for my taste. I like successful people, but not those who dress in armors of arrogance. But unlike toadies in the media, I respect Mr. Trump for his straight talk, his willingness to call our enemies by name, and his calling-out of the press for what it has become – a shill for the Left’s elite.

The Left’s defense of Comey would be humorous were it not so destructive to democratic principles. They want Trump gone, regardless of the cost. If that is not possible, they want to impede his policy proposals: tax reform, healthcare and the reconstruction of our highways and bridges. Special counsels, in the past, have proven to be politically biased, ineffectual and expensive. If Congress really believes that Mr. Trump violated the law they should conduct their own investigation and determine whether he should be impeached. Trying him in the media only aggravates dissonance.

Democracies can withstand the bombast of crude politicians who move around Washington like bulls in a china shop, and who are regularly ridiculed in the media. Democracies are at risk to smooth and articulate talkers who hide motives behind eloquent, but deceptive words, words that conceal insidious subversions – those who subtlety and imperceptibly assimilate power under the guise of doing good.

But, when unelected bureaucrats assume powers that are not theirs, they should be let go. Mr. Comey exceeded his responsibilities. He was fired for cause. That was a good thing, an expected thing – a “dog bites man” story. It should never have become a “man bites dog” story. And that is concerning.



Labels: , , ,

Monday, October 17, 2016

"Public Pensions: Promises Promises"

Sydney M. Williams

Thought of the Day
“Public Pensions: Promises Promises”
October 17, 2016

“You made me promises promises
Knowing I’d believe
Promises promises
You knew you’d never keep.”
                                                                                             From the Neil Simon musical “Promises Promises” – 1968
                                                                                             Lyrics by Hal David
                                                                                             Score by Burt Bacharach

The end of liberalism is not an original thought, but it is a possibility. In 1969 (revised in 1979), Theodore J. Lowi, professor of government at Cornell, published The End of Liberalism: The Second Republic of the United States. He argued that government had become too big and that interest groups had caused Congress to cede responsibilities to unelected (and, in some cases, unaccountable) agencies. These agencies, including the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), control more than a trillion dollars in annual expenditures – almost 25% of all federal spending. Ironically for Democrats, special interest groups have created another problem – they compete with unionized government, and the demands public-sector retirees exact from American taxpayers.

Today, global progressives see the end of liberalism in the rise of nativism, xenophobia and populism – manifested in decisions such as Brexit, the Republican nomination of Trump and the Colombia-FARC Accord. It is seen in the failure of the Arab Spring and the resurgence of Putin’s Russia and Xi’s China. Conservatives bemoan the unraveling of liberal values, which date to the age of enlightenment – the acceptance of anti-Western ideologies, cultural and moral relativism, and political correctness. The latter denies language from being used as it was intended – to accurately describe people, their actions and events.

I do not pretend to know if “liberalism” is at an end. What I believe is that big, activist government is being hoisted with its own petard. Promises have been made that will prove impossible to keep. Activist government was conceived in the belief that equality of outcomes supersedes that of opportunity. In the United States, “big” government was born during the New Deal, reached maturity in LBJ’s Great Society, and has come into senescence with ObamaCare and the CFPB; it is seen in the Administration’s videos: “Life of Julia” and “Pajama Boy.” The factors progressives cite allow them to ignore what seems an inevitability – that promises politicians made to those who elected them will not be possible to keep.

This is a world-wide problem, moving in slow-motion toward crisis. Citigroup recently identified nine countries where public sector pension liabilities (not included in debt figures) exceed more than 300% of their respective GDP – Austria, Britain, Denmark, France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Portugal and Spain. 

Progressives talk of “fairness,” when the conversation should be about saving a foundering ship. They talk of the one-percent not paying their “fair share,” when, in fact, they pay half of all federal income taxes. They say government is the answer, when what is needed is faster economic growth – requiring less regulation and flatter, lower tax rates, less government. They want to protect young people from “harmful words,” to grow up without the challenges and hardships that are part of everyday life. They find “victimization” everywhere, and then wonder why civility has receded.

The consequence of Goldilocks-like promises are most prominent in the public pension arena. Last Monday, the New York Times ran the story of tiny (700 people) Loyalton, California, a small town with four retired public employees. In 2012, the town opted out of CalPERS (California Public Employees Retirement System), because the annual cost of $30,000 was crimping their budget. CalPERS then sent the town a bill for $1,600,000 to fully fund the pensions of the four retirees, else annual pension payments would be reduced by about 60 percent. CalPERS only fully funds pension plans when a participant chooses to leave. They assume (probably correctly) that if an exception is made to Loyalton, the rest of the 3,007 participating governments will want similar treatment. Four people and the forgiveness of $1,600,000 doesn’t seem like much for a fund with total assets of $290 billion. But, could CalPERS afford to treat the other 560,000 retired public pensioners as liberally? Should contract law be abrogated so dismissively?

In August, Pensions & Investments wrote of a Pension Finance Task Force (PFTF), a joint effort created by the American Academy of Actuaries (AAA) and the Society of Actuaries (SoA).  The task force was not allowed to publish their findings. They had concluded that, since public pension plans are purported to be default-free obligations, they should use default-free interest rates when determining the discount rate to estimate returns and calculate future obligations. For example, the risk-free yield on the 30-Year Treasury is 2.5 percent. Yet the current actuarial practice is to use 7.5 percent. The more conservative number would add significantly to liabilities.  The Economist recently suggested that using a discount rate of 4% would mean that the average public pension fund would have a funding ratio of 45%, not the 72% used by the Center for Retirement Research. Using the higher rate makes funding look less of a problem than it is. It is delusional, at a time when $12 trillion in global debt has been issued at negative interest rates.

This is a big problem. Five states – Connecticut, Massachusetts, New Jersey, Illinois and Kentucky – have the largest unfunded liabilities. New Jersey has the highest pension debt per resident: $15,000. The underfunded portion of Illinois pensions has increased 500% since 1995, and 75% in the past five years! Scranton (PA) city auditors calculated that police and fire pension funds will be depleted in three to five years. If the discount rate used was actually the Thirty-year Treasury, estimates suggest the shortfall would exceed $3 trillion, instead of the $968 billion reported for fiscal 2013. Stephen Moore, writing in Investors’ Business Daily two years ago, put the unfunded number between one and five trillion dollars.

There are no easy solutions for a country with generous public retirement benefits and an aging population, apart from simply expunging the elderly, an unappealing suggestion to me. The best option – grow the economy. Other measures include: an increase in tax rates, which would hamper economic growth; raise retirement ages, which would further worsen youth employment; reduce contractually agreed-to pension payments, which may be illegal; convert existing and future plans from defined benefit to defined contribution plans, which will have to be done. It will probably take some combination. It is not unionization per se that is the problem. It is the willingness of politicians to make promises they cannot keep. Unions, though, are not innocent. In 2014, four public sector unions (NEA, AFT, SEIU and the AFSC&ME) contributed $85.6 million to political campaigns, with all but $210,000 going to profligate Democrats.

ObamaCare has made entitlements costlier. Debt, will increase should Hillary Clinton’s plan to provide free public college education be adopted. Debt and pension obligations have hampered infrastructure rebuild and military preparedness. They are a reason the Fed has kept interest rates so low. God help us, should we again face a crisis as we did in 1941, 2001 and 2008. Politicians should address these concerns. Thus far they have chosen a broom and a carpet.

“Promises promises you knew you’d never keep.” But at some point the piper must be paid.




Labels: , ,

Monday, September 26, 2016

"Climate: The Politicization of Science"

Sydney M. Williams

Thought of the Day
“Climate: The Politicization of Science”
September 26, 2016

 “It will be like weather forecasting on earth…
One can’t predict the weather more than a few days in advance.”
                                                                               Stephan Hawkins (1942-)
                                                                               Information, Preservation and Weather Forecasting for Black Holes, 2014

“If you don’t like the weather in New England now, just wait a few minutes,” is a saying generally attributed to Mark Twain, a Missouri native, but Hartford resident for seventeen years. Having grown up in New Hampshire and having lived my adult life in Connecticut, I can attest to the validity of his observation.

At a time when politicians (and politics) have become more divisive than at any point since the 1960s, few issues generate more hyperbole than “climate change,” or “global warming,” as it was called last year. Climate, as those of us from New England well know, is in constant flux and always has been. Global warming is a phenomenon that appears to be fact…at least in certain parts of the world. Arctic ice caps are shrinking, but those in Antarctica are getting bigger. During the 1970s, the media was concerned about global cooling. Over millennia, the earth has warmed and cooled thousands of times. Mountains have risen, seas have been altered and deserts and jungles created…all before the advent of man.

William Happer, a physicist at Princeton and former director of the Department of Energy’s Office of Science during the first Bush administration recently wrote a paper, “Harmful Politicization of Science.” He has been maligned by those who forbid counter-arguments to the narrative that man bears responsibility for climate change. In the paper, Professor Happer explained he did not see great risk in warming trends, as they have not reached the same intensity as they had from roughly 900 AD to 1250 AD when Vikings settled Iceland and Greenland. He wrote: “The current debates about global climate change are complicated by our not understanding the physics of the sun or the earth’s atmosphere and oceans well enough to dismiss them as major causes of climate change on the earth.” Is his skepticism ill-informed?

The Left’s adamancy assumes that the science of climate change is settled – that all relevant knowledge has been considered, that answers are known. If we reduce our emissions all will be well? It is an attitude not dissimilar to those who said the earth was flat, or that we were the center of the universe. The truth is that the search for scientific answers is more akin to Stuart Little’s quest for Margalo…we may feel we are on the right path, but the quest continues. The risks in their simplistic, but politically expedient responses are that their focus detracts from could be a real need to adapt, as life has had to do since it first appeared billions of years ago – not to try to change what may not be changeable, but to adapt. It was adaption that caused people to move to low-lying islands a thousand or more years ago. They may have to move again.

While I am a skeptic as to causes, I also believe we have a responsibility to treat the planet with respect and to improve the environment wherever we can. And that is what man has done, especially over the past century. It is our wealth (ironically, much of it derived from natural resources) that has allowed man to clean up the environment. A Hundred years ago, the Connecticut River, in whose valley I reside, was far dirtier than it is today. Seventy-five years ago, most of New York City’s apartments were heated by coal. Fifty years ago Los Angeles was smog-bound. It is natural for our species to improve our habitats.

But, if one disagrees with the assertion that “climate change” is the greatest risk we face and that man bears principal responsibility, one is labeled a “denier.” End of debate. Senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI) even urged that “deniers” be prosecuted. Such allegations and charges are both asinine and nescient. They are used for political advantage. “Believers” express opinions as fact, based on observations that accord with a preconceived narrative. They brook no dissension. Whatever happened to scientific inquiry? Whatever happened to free speech?

At some point the earth will end, but probably not for a billion or more years. Whether it explodes because its orbit carries it too close to the sun, or if the sun burns out and the earth becomes nothing more than a frozen planet veering off into space, I don’t know, and, I suspect no one else does either. But man will likely not be the cause. Did man cause the continents to split, or the Sahara Deserts to develop seven million years ago? Did man cause Vesuvius to erupt 2,000 years ago, or the Rocky Mountains to arise seventy million years ago? The earth has been around for a few billion years. Was man responsible for the earthquake that devastated Shaanxi, China in 1556, which killed almost two-thirds of the region’s population, or the heavy rains that flooded the Yangtze River in 1931 that took 3.7 million lives? Did man cause Katrina, which devastated New Orleans in 2004, or the earthquake in San Francisco in 1906?  How much more time does the earth have? Can anyone answer? To claim that one can is fatuous. I am not a denier; I am, though, skeptical of those who claim that the science of climate change is settled.

Technology has allowed us to anticipate and to monitor hurricanes like Sandy or typhoons like Haiyan, but we cannot stop them, or even re-direct them. We can warn people; but the energy they release is greater than anything man has ever devised. In a 2006 article written for NASA’s publication Earth Observatory, science writers Steve Graham and Holli Riebeek wrote: “…during its life cycle a hurricane can expend as much energy as 10,000 nuclear bombs.” Which should we fear most: one of nature’s devastating storms, an unfortunate movement of one of the earth’s tectonic plates, or a coal-fired plant in Kentucky or another in Inner Mongolia? While we can do something about coal plants, there is little, at this point, that we can do to subdue nature when she decides to act up.

No one denies the changing climate of our planet. And no one I know denies that man bears some responsibility. The question is how critical has man’s role been? I submit that no one knows. It has been the politicization of the issue that I find reprehensible. It is offensive when individuals with whom we have entrusted our nation’s highest offices – people like Al Gore – exploit climate change for personal gain. Scientists should be encouraged to continue to seek answers.

Do you truly believe that the science of climate is “settled,” that we know all there is to know, that there is no knowledge yet to be gained? It was once “settled” science that the earth was flat and that our planet was the center of the universe, that man could not fly. The earth is large and complex, and scientists can only guess at its measurements. Its weight is estimated at 1.3 X 10(25) pounds; yet it ‘floats’ in space. Its land mass (about 30% of its surface) covers about 196.9 million square miles. Its oceans – 97% of its water – contain (according to NOAA) 321 million cubic miles of water. The earth’s center – four thousand miles beneath where you now sit – is composed of molten iron, with a temperature estimated at 10,800°F.  Its age, estimated at 4 billion years, is a moving target. The United Nations Environment Program estimates that there are 8,700,000 species on earth, “give or take a million.” Man is but one. And, keep in mind, the earth is but a speck in the universe. We know a lot, but there is much we have to learn.

To claim that the elimination of greenhouse gasses will cause the planet to cool and seas to recede is not only disingenuous, it is dangerous. Doctrinaire advocates of climate change have turned what should be a bi-partisan field of research for the benefit of all into a politicization of science for the gain of a few.


Labels: , ,